After the UC Bearcats beat Ohio State on the way to a 12-1 record, a national ranking and a trip to the Liberty Bowl, Cincinnati city council gave Rick Minter a key to what's left of the city and proclaimed Dec. 31, 2002 George Murray Day.

"If George's fingers had been butter instead of glue, he wouldn't have made that great catch in the end zone on third down," mayor Charlie Luken said, "and our town would still be groveling in shame beneath the overwhelming stench of the Bengals." Luken praised Murray and UC for saving the financially strapped city from having to provide gas masks to every Bengals fan with a personal seat license.

"We had a chance for the biggest win in school history," Minter said to the overflow crowd jamming Fountain Square, "and we took it."

Well, not quite.

OHIO STATE 23, UC 19

UC's George Murray anguishes after dropping a last-minute pass in the end zone. • Photo gallery • Main story

Murray let that third-down pass slip from his hands, UC finished 7-7 and the Buckeyes are unbeaten and playing Friday for a national title. What Rick Minter really said was: "We had a chance for the biggest win in school history. We let an opportunity slip by that we might regret."

You don't get many chances of a lifetime. There is never a day when you tell your grandchildren about things you almost did, so Minter tries not to spend time thinking about how his team nearly beat Ohio State on Sept.21.

The Buckeyes rallied to beat UC 23-19 in front of the biggest crowd in Cincinnati sports history. The game foreshadowed perfectly the rest of the season for each school. UC lost all its close games and the Buckeyes won all theirs. One-in-a-million came and went. What remained for UC was pats on the head from a well-meaning public.

"The perception makes you sick sometimes," Minter said. "You know: You made it so close, you should feel good. A lot of people have said to me, `If you'd just won the Ohio State game, think what you'd have done.' We could have gained many, many things by winning."

What if the Bearcats had won? Would Gino Guidugli be wearing the Greg Cook hero suit? Can you imagine UC football being the talk of the town, zealous fans hosting Liberty Bowl parties, Antwan Peek bobbleheads going for $500 on eBay?

Look at the extended party we threw the Elder football team. The Panthers won a state title and we were so hungry for any jock triumph, we honored them like firemen in New York. What if UC had finished the regular season 12-1?

What about the Buckeyes? What if Matt Wilhelm doesn't tip Guidugli's fourth-down pass and Will Allen doesn't pick it off? What happens if Murray's fingers really are glue?

Does OSU rebound to win all those close games? No team was tougher mentally or more resilient than the '02 Bucks. Some of that character was forged at UC's expense. If UC wins Sept.21, do the Buckeyes beat Purdue on fourth-and-1? Do they escape in overtime at Illinois? Character isn't assumed, no matter how good you are; it's earned.

If UC wins, does Ohio State lose one or two of the five other games it won by a touchdown or less? Do the Buckeyes play in the Rose Bowl consolation game and bring home second-place prizes chosen just for them? Or do they slide all the way down to the Capital One Bowl, formerly the Citrus Bowl, formerly OSU's home away from home?

"Ohio State has the basic ingredients all good teams have," Minter said. "They stop the run, they don't give up a lot of big plays, they don't make the mistakes that lose you close games, they don't ask their quarterback or anyone else to do anything they're not capable of doing. Really, Ohio State is what we want to be."

No one is saying UC will ever be OSU, especially not Minter. But the Bearcats outgained the Bucks, 415 yards to 292; they led 19-17 until OSU scored with 3:44 to play. They drove to a first down at the Ohio State 15 with a minute left.

"Looking back now, when I talk with our offensive coaches, we didn't have to throw four straight times into the end zone," Minter said.

They did, though, and they missed them all. The key to the city remains in city hall. Rick Minter hopes once in a lifetime happens twice.

E-mail pdaugherty@enquirer.com

SEE CINERGY IMPLOSION
Animation from Enquirer photos
Video from WCPO
Galleries: Implosion | Crowd | Aerial shots | Views from Kentucky

CINERGY IMPLOSION STORIES
What's next for the Riverfront?
New skyline already earning praise
Cinergy Field down in 37 seconds
Implosion called 'perfect event'
Partiers impressed by implosion
Fifty-five years that shaped Cincinnati's riverfront

BENGALS GAMEDAY
Bills 27, Bengals 9
Game might be LeBeau's last
Mooshagian to interview for college job
Isolation Booth: TKO Vs. Bledsoe
Keys to the game
Bengals-Bills by the numbers
The Edge
Life as a Rookie

AROUND THE NFL
This week's NFL picks, power rankings
If winning is only stat that matters, give McNair MVP
Giants 10, Eagles 7
Raiders 24, Chiefs 0
Home not so sweet for Browns
Colts in, but are they ready?
The playoff picture remains unclear

UC BEARCATS
UC 66, Miami 54
Fouls hurt RedHawks
UC-Miami Notebook: Hicks comes back
DAUGHERTY: What if UC had beaten OSU?

WOMEN'S CROSSTOWN SHOOTOUT
UC women beat Xavier with defense
Ex-Bearcats, Pirtle say hello

XAVIER
No. 21 Xavier 84, Eastern Kentucky 60

OTHER COLLEGE BASKETBALL NEWS
Pitino's rebuilt Cardinals rout Wildcats
Stone's redemption - UK's nightmare
Ohio State 94, Tennessee State 73
Temple 71, No. 10 Indiana 64
Saturday's Top 25 roundup
NKU men top Ferris St. to reach perfect 10

FIESTA BOWL
Buckeyes wary Miami has speed to burn
Close wins got Miami, OSU to Tempe
Buckeyes' home away from home is isolated in desert
Five questions with John Gonsior

OTHER COLLEGE FOOTBALL NEWS
Brooks hired as UK football coach
Alamo goes to Badgers in OT
Lundy powers Virginia to win
Bowls at a glance

PREP SPORTS
Ohio boys: No. 1 Bacon loses first game
Ky. boys: Dixie gives Draud 100th win
Ohio girls: No. 2 Mercy runs away from Notre Dame
Ky. girls: Campbell wins Ryle challenge with 73-46 win
Hockey: Powell too much for Moeller
Preps schedules, results

BASEBALL
Reds Q&A
Prospects aren't improving for Orioles
It's goodbye to an era
Final countdown on Cinergy Field
Riverfront timeline

PRO HOOPS
NBA: Riley, ref ignore each other
Local players in the NBA

HOCKEY
Kariya plays despite death of father
Ducks go down; Cyclones roll

TRISTATE SPOTLIGHT
Area players' bowl (games) runneth over
Enquirer's Page Two power rankings

PLAN YOUR DAY
Sports on TV, radio this weekend