County says key phrase omitted in Chiquita case

Friday, December 4, 1998

BY DAN HORN
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Prosecutors say they inadvertently left out a key phrase in the indictment against the lawyer accused of stealing voice-mail messages from Chiquita Brands International Inc.

In a motion filed Thursday in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court, special prosecutor Perry Ancona asked a judge to allow him to change the wording of the charges against Salt Lake City attorney George Ventura.

Mr. Ancona said he wants to add a phrase that was omitted "through clerical error and inadvertence."

The request refers to the final five counts of the 10-count indictment against Mr. Ventura and involves the felony charge of unauthorized access to computer systems.

Mr. Ancona's request to Judge Ann Marie Tracey states that the phrase is important because it makes it clear no one associated with Chiquita gave Mr. Ventura permission to access the voice-mail system.

He said the phrase -- "or other person authorized to give consent by the owner" -- specifies that Mr. Ventura did not receive permission from the company.

Although Mr. Ancona's motion refers to his request as a "clerical" matter, Mr. Ventura's attorney said he is considering whether to oppose the request. "Any effort to change an indictment after it's been returned is a serious matter," said defense attorney Marc Mezibov.

The charges against Mr. Ventura, a former legal counsel for Chiquita, stem from a grand jury investigation into allegations that The Cincinnati Enquirer used stolen voice-mail messages in articles it published in May about the company.

The newspaper later renounced the articles in a front-page apology, fired the lead reporter and paid Chiquita more than $10 million.



Local Headlines For Friday, December 4, 1998

$1.8M in state budget for Clermont projects
2nd arson stuns school
Boehner says he'll vote to impeach
Church will rebuild after fire
Cincy man is co-chief for Taft
City says officer who took photos didn't break law
County says key phrase omitted in Chiquita case
Downtown detours this weekend
Election financing cut from inquiry
Fingerprints from Miami analyzed
Fox blasts custody decision against grandmother
Gambling review dropped
Governor's term: 12 days
Human rights work called unfinished
Judges to seek re-election
Klan says new cross will be sturdier
Ky. shooting suspect nabbed
Liberty Twp. fights annexation
Lopez-Cobos asks to bow out
Man under stay-away order kills girlfriend, self
N.Ky. schools improve on tests
Newport picks home-grown city manager
Obstacles stall drug program
Officer, motorist critical
OHIO CHAMPIONSHIP PREVIEW
Panel: Get tougher on crime
Parents lose 2 sons in 2 days
Prosecution: Former firefighter could be serial rapist
Prosecutor winds up Corporex case
Schools risk loss of property
Schools tested, not kids
Stick it to the Klan: Help those they hate
Teens report less smoking, drinking, drugs
Test trends, facts
TRISTATE DIGEST
Trucks can't duck police
Voinovich wary of move to cut taxes
Warrior mania moves north today
Winton Woods to get athletic building
Women's health conference peers into next century