Sunday, May 23, 1999

Advocates continue fighting execution


Appeal for stay filed in federal appeals court

BY BEN L. KAUFMAN
The Cincinnati Enquirer

        Kentucky public advocates Saturday asked a federal appeals court to stay the execution of Edward Lee Harper Jr., who says he is tired of appealing and prefers to die.

        Advocates Randall L. Wheeler and Susan M. J. Martin say Mr. Harper is incompetent to volunteer to accept lethal injection at 7 p.m. CDT on Tuesday.

        If the effort fails, he will be the first Kentucky inmate to volunteer to die since the U.S. Supreme Court allowed resumption of capital punishment.

        Mr. Harper was convicted in Jefferson Circuit Court in 1982 of murdering his adoptive parents.

        Appeals in state courts failed, and last month he told U.S. District Judge Joseph McKinney in Louisville that he would forgo a federal appeal.

        At a two-day hearing last week, Judge McKinney ruled that Mr. Harper was competent to fire the advocates and accept execution by injection at the Kentucky State Penitentiary at Eddyville.

        The judge was wrong on both issues, the advocates said.

        Part of the problem was assurance from Judge McKinney that the only issue last week was whether Mr. Harper requires a full-blown competency hearing.

        Instead, they said, the judge used the preliminary hearing to resolve both questions and remove final barriers to the death chamber.

        That denied Mr. Harper the probing evidentiary hearing required to judge his competence, the advocates said, and they have been handicapped by court denial of funds to hire experts needed to rebut state witnesses.

        The advocates said Mr. Harper is wildly delusional and requires an updated psychiatric evaluation, especially given recently uncovered evidence of disabling mental illnesses suffered by his birth mother and many of her relatives.

        The initial state response filed Saturday said Judge McKinney used the correct standard for judging Mr. Harper's competence.

        Further, they said, the advocates no longer represent Mr. Harper and have no standing to pursue the appeal.

        An explicit response to the motion for a stay is expected by reopening of U.S. Court of Appeals for the 6th Circuit in Cincinnati on Monday.

       



Jobs lure Hispanic immigrants to Tristate
Illegal worker cases are low priority for INS
Illegal workers live life in shadows
The aftermath of 'teen violence'
A loud cheer for intolerance in our schools
What's the big idea?
Tristate lawmakers wary of new controls on guns
Truth about teen-agers found at Ryle
Ad points up Sen. Bunning's support from gun lobby
Hazardous chemicals around high school raise cancer fears
Mom, son, 7 share arrest
Renovations divide church
'99 council race is prologue to '01
- Advocates continue fighting execution
Parole vote ahead for cop killer
Republicans miss big chance
Only CBS lineup has some shows for all generations
GET TO IT
Rebuilder of cities calls for more culture
Summer movies strike back
Systems help deaf, blind enjoy movies in theater
Conference boosts endangered beasts
Developers stymied by sidewalks
Festival honors area youth
Hazards get a new approach
Opening-week aquarium attendance meets expectations
Organ donation standards could widen at conference
Police exam must be redone
Springboro weaves tales of its 19th century heritage
TRISTATE DIGEST