Thursday, August 12, 1999
Justin's parents drop suit
Custody fight for boy continues
BY SUSAN VELA
The Cincinnati Enquirer
COVINGTON The biological parents of 2-year-old Justin, caught in a two-state adoption battle, have decided to stop pursuing a civil lawsuit against the Girard, Ohio, couple that wants to adopt him.
Eric Deters, attorney for biological parents Regina Moore and Jerry Dorning of Covington, said the suit was dismissed for practical reasons. But the Ohio couple, Rich and Cheryl Asente, con tend they never put much stock in it anyway.
I thought it was kind of frivolous, Mr. Asente said. This was about money. If anyone had the right to sue for breach of contract, it was the opposite.
Mr. Asente questioned why the biological parents would try to get damages from them when they already have about $200,000 in legal fees and are raising Ms. Moore's and Mr. Dorning's other biological son, Joey, now 3, whom they formally adopted. Justin still lives with them, too.
In essence, they're bankrupting Joey's parents, Mr. Asente said.
However, it was just a practical and strategic reason, Mr. Deters said of the decision to not pursue the civil lawsuit in Kenton Circuit Court. It was simply a pragmatic decision.
There is so much going on. With all that is going on in both Ohio and Kentucky, it's my opinion that no court would ever award or inject themselves on a breach of contract issue.
Mr. Deters still is repre senting Justin's biological parents in the litigation filed against their former attorney, Thomas Donnelly, for negligence. That lawsuit will be at a standstill until Justin's custody is decided.
When Justin was almost a year old, he was sent to live with the Asentes. She and Mr. Dorning had signed consent forms to start adoption proceedings, but only with the understanding that they would have time to change their minds.
They did, and the couple has been fighting to have the child returned to them almost ever since. Meanwhile, the Asentes have refused their request and have been trying to adopt the child in Ohio since June, 1998.
Kenton Circuit Judge Patricia Summe ruled earlier this year that Justin must be returned to his biological parents because they did not make an informed decision when they let the original placement happen.
Meanwhile, an Ohio judge ruled Ohio had jurisdiction and ruled the adoption case should proceed.
The Asentes have appealed the Kentucky ruling with the Kentucky Supreme Court, which is pending, and an Aug. 24 hearing is set before the Ohio Court of Appeals so that attorneys for both couples can make arguments about which state Ohio or Kentucky should have jurisdiction of the case.
No matter the decision, Columbus attorney Susan Eisenman, who is representing the Asentes, already has said that she expects the case to advance to the Ohio Supreme Court. But she's thankful that one legal battle has been dismissed.
Fountain going under cover
Cross-river call will require extra digit
Making a silk purse from a cow's ear
Explosion causes Florence fire
Priest on leave, admits paternity
Aronoff charged with DUI in crash
City schools seek $24 million
Five more become ill from E. coli
Lakota adopts drug policy
Man dies of injuries in hit-skip accident
Mother convicted of deadly beating
Blood donations pick up
Girl admits at trial she lied about rape
Justin's parents drop suit
Man charged with pharmacy break-ins
Public housing made better
Controversial show brings in crowds
WLW crossed line
Bra straps have gone from taboo to trend
GET TO IT
Villa Hills teen's violin soars
Ambulance use to cost nonresidents
Attempt to aid dog nets $100 ticket
Boone Co. prioritizes road projects
Clermont seeks bids on projects
Columbus police step up guard for Jewish games
County allots green for parks
County races to lay utility lines
Defendant convicted of legal sham
High temperatures could send students home early
Houston men charged in jewelry store burglary
Man convicted in second trial
Paintings stolen from downtown gallery
Residents want aquatic center
State may decide on district split
Still no clues in case of body found on farmland
Suit delays enforcement of state abortion law
Taft ducks water plan, groups say
Thrill of flying found in rig
Township ponders how to fund police
Transit center final designs to be unveiled
'Trashtrap' boat cleans up Ky. lake
Two resisting term limits
Visit by principal can be fun