Thursday, August 12, 1999

Mother convicted of deadly beating

Jury acquits on murder charge

The Cincinnati Enquirer

        Belanda Moore was convicted Wednesday of beating her 7-year-old daughter so severely that the girl died hours later from her injuries.

        But she avoided a murder conviction because the jury could not agree on whether she knew her actions could kill.

        After two days of tense deliberations, the jury returned with guilty verdicts for involuntary manslaughter and child endangering.

        The jurors were unable to reach unanimous verdicts on three other charges: murder, felonious assault and a second count of child endangering.

        “It was very, very tense,” one of the jurors, Joe Wessling, said of the deliberations. “It was extremely controversial.”

        Although Ms. Moore, 29, of Winton Hills is now facing up to 18 years in prison, prosecutors still could pursue a conviction on the remaining charges at another trial.

        Several jurors, including Mr. Wessling, said they supported a conviction on the other charges but could not muster enough votes for a unanimous verdict on any of them.

        During the trial, Assistant Prosecutor Richard Gibson argued that Ms. Moore beat her daughter, Jasmine, on Feb. 12 for misbehaving at school. He said she used a rolled belt and “stomped” on her chest.

        As Jasmine died slowly from a lacerated liver, Mr. Gibson said, Ms. Moore drank vodka and played cards all night with her friends.

        Jury foreman Ken Weyer said the most hotly debated charge was the second count of child endangering, which alleged that Ms. Moore failed to seek medical attention for her injured daughter.

        “That was difficult,” Mr. Weyer said. “Two and possibly three people on that jury would not have found my mother guilty of my birth because they weren't there at the time of the conception.

        “They kept saying they couldn't convict because they weren't there.”

        He said the jurors voted 10-2 for conviction on the disputed child-endangering charge and 9-3 for conviction on felonious assault.

        Mr. Weyer said the murder vote was 7-5 for acquittal.

        Ms. Moore's attorney, Pete Rosenwald, said he was optimistic prosecutors would “see the futility” of another trial.

        “They got their conviction,” he said.

        The case was the first jury trial in Hamilton County involving a new state law that allows prosecutors to seek murder charges when a defen dant causes a death while in the act of committing a violent felony.

        Under the old law, murder charges could be used only if the defendant “purposely caused the death of another.”

        So a key issue in Ms. Moore's case was whether she “knowingly” used violence that could result in death.

        Mr. Rosenwald called the new law “an abomination” and said the jury made the right choice.

        “It's manslaughter, not murder,” he said.

        Prosecutor Mike Allen said he would decide within the next few days whether to seek another trial on the remaining charges. Judge Robert Kraft will meet with the attorneys Aug. 19 to discuss the next step.


Fountain going under cover
Cross-river call will require extra digit
Making a silk purse from a cow's ear
Explosion causes Florence fire
Priest on leave, admits paternity
Aronoff charged with DUI in crash
City schools seek $24 million
Five more become ill from E. coli
Lakota adopts drug policy
Man dies of injuries in hit-skip accident
- Mother convicted of deadly beating
Blood donations pick up
Girl admits at trial she lied about rape
Justin's parents drop suit
Man charged with pharmacy break-ins
Public housing made better
Controversial show brings in crowds
WLW crossed line
Bra straps have gone from taboo to trend
Villa Hills teen's violin soars
Ambulance use to cost nonresidents
Attempt to aid dog nets $100 ticket
Boone Co. prioritizes road projects
Clermont seeks bids on projects
Columbus police step up guard for Jewish games
County allots green for parks
County races to lay utility lines
Defendant convicted of legal sham
High temperatures could send students home early
Houston men charged in jewelry store burglary
Man convicted in second trial
Paintings stolen from downtown gallery
Residents want aquatic center
State may decide on district split
Still no clues in case of body found on farmland
Suit delays enforcement of state abortion law
Taft ducks water plan, groups say
Thrill of flying found in rig
Township ponders how to fund police
Transit center final designs to be unveiled
'Trashtrap' boat cleans up Ky. lake
Two resisting term limits
Visit by principal can be fun