Sunday, August 15, 1999

Hamilton considers razing downtown building


Opposition argues for historic value

BY DAVID ECK
Enquirer Contributor

        HAMILTON - Over the last 68 years, the building near Hamilton's City Hall has been a bus terminal, a dry cleaner and has housed offices. Now preservationists hope the building itself doesn't become history.

        They plan to fight a proposal to demolish the building at 40 High St.

        City Council in several weeks could move to raze the city-owned building, which some council members say would cost too much to revi talize. The building was attached to the old Rialto Theater, which was torn down several years ago.

        “We've had water leakage,” said council member Sharon Hughes. “It hasn't been cared for in a long time.”

        She said it would take about $200,000 to make the structure usable and $600,000 to restore it. It will cost about $40,000 to demolish, not including costs to salvage parts of the facade, which Ms. Hughes would like to see happen if it is razed.

        Plans call for the land to be used as green space.

        “This is not a death knell for historic buildings in downtown Hamilton,” Ms. Hughes said. “It's not a snap judgment. Un fortunately, I really think it's going to come down.”

        Not if Ann Antenen has her way.

        “People are getting tired of having their community destroyed by politicians who don't care about how their community looks,” said Mrs. Antenen, president of Citizens for Historic Preservation Services. “They think demolition is the answer to everything.”

        She will spend the weekend sending out postcards to about 300 Hamilton residents urging them to oppose razing the structure.

        “To me it's very disappointing,” she said. “There are more than six people who care about that building.”

        She said the council has worked with her and other preservationists in the past to save historic buildings such as the Anthony Wayne Hotel and the Robinson-Schwenn building, a former opera house.

        “They're doing all these wonderful things,” Mrs. Antenen said. “It's got us a little confused.”

        But when Hamilton bought the structure near City Hall several years ago for offices, the plan was to demolish the building, said Mayor Tom Nye.

        “It was never the intention of the city to preserve the structures that were on that land,” said Mr. Nye, who lives in an historic neighborhood. “There's nothing, zero, historic inside. It's not without great reluctance that I, as a preservationist, and the rest of council, do this.”

        He said that over the years the building was gutted of any historical features.

        “If you wanted to make it appear to be historic, you would simply have to start all over. You can't create heritage. Just because something's old doesn't mean it needs to be saved.”

        If the building does come down, the facade and other parts should be saved to be incorporated into other structures, Ms. Hughes said.

        But that could backfire, Mrs. Antenen said.

        “It's a constant reminder when you do that,” she said.

       



Hit-skip driver gives up
What do we do with surplus?
What readers said
GOP taps Portman to open tax debate
Family ledger a precious record
Family's history rises from slavery
'And the slaves were set free'
Women burned in acid attacks to get care here
Banks hold the gun in this stickup
Activists protest festival game of rodent roulette
What if Buffett does waste away?
'Blair Witch' offers filmmakers hope
Where were you in '72?
Alleged fake ID maker arrested
Dimmer school means brighter future for Abby
'I did it' won't always merit lesser sentence
Introducing! The governor! (Yawn)
Readers get their turn to be heard
S-curve work alters traffic
Springer race wasn't meant to be
A postcard from that place where I find peace
Rocco to flex those molars
Chickens take roost in sculpture
CSO launches ad campaign
Ensemble interns gear up for year
GET TO IT
Like it or not, Boone County needs a sewage plant
At age 101, she's ahead of the trend
Billfold lost, but honesty wasn't
Creeks get a well-needed cleaning
Dogs keeping birds off runway
Exodus to Israel
- Hamilton considers razing downtown building
Horse breeders fondly remember 'daddy' of Rocky Mountain line
Norwood gets Even Start grant
One Deters campaigns for another
Owner fights blight label
Retired executives share skills
TRISTATE DIGEST