Thursday, December 02, 1999

Sides at trial describe killing

Accused claims self-defense

The Cincinnati Enquirer

        HAMILTON — The attorneys for Manuel Ramirez Garcia said Wednesday that he shot Jose Juan Hernandez in self-defense on June 25 on a Hamilton street.

        “Mr. Garcia was in fear for his life,” defense attorney Brian Goodyear said in his opening statement at Mr. Garcia's murder trial in Butler County Common Pleas Court.

        But assistant prosecutor Pat Moeller said Mr. Garcia shot an unarmed Mr. Hernandez several times in retaliation for offensive comments the man had made to him.

        As Mr. Hernandez lay bleeding on the ground, Mr. Garcia approached him and shot him two more times, he said.

        Mr. Garcia, 21, of Hamilton, is charged with murder. His jury trial began Wednesday before Judge Patricia Oney. The shooting occurred in the 700 block of Buckeye Street.

        During this trial, a professional interpreter is sitting next to Mr. Garcia, a native of Mexico, and is translating proceedings into Spanish for him.

        After the shooting, Mr. Garcia ran to his girlfriend's house and hid in a bedroom closet, Mr. Moeller said. The Hamilton police flushed him out with tear gas.

        Mr. Garcia told police two or three conflicting stories. He told one officer that he had to kill Mr. Hernandez or be killed, Mr. Moeller said.

        “Mr. Garcia said Mr. Hernandez said offensive things to him,” he said. “He said Mr. Hernandez had to pay for the things he said to him.”

        Later, Mr. Garcia told police that he shot toward the ground and didn't know if he had shot Mr. Hernandez when he ran away, Mr. Moeller said.

        Mr. Goodyear said Mr. Hernandez had struck Mr. Garcia with a beer bottle earlier that evening. He said Mr. Hernandez pulled out a gun, and Mr. Garcia tried to grab it. “There was a struggle,” Mr. Goodyear said. “During the struggle, at least two shots were fired.” He said gunpowder residue found on one of Mr. Hernandez's hands proved that he held the gun.


The liberating plastic world of Tupperware
Parents want 'real facts'
Consumers picky about 2000 mementos
Mrs. Clinton here collecting
'Coach' arrested for rape of boy
Luken: Council's 'plate is full'
Noted fathers on sidelines as sons, daughter take office
34-year-old memory lost, found in sewer
Area guardsmen headed to Kuwait
Hamilton takes cameras to streets
Plans for Hustler store gain momentum
Put yourself in historic photograph
Schools' zero tolerance debated
Teachers union complains about substitute hiring
Adamowski contract extension too early
ADD parents' challenge: Focus on practical ideas
Addressing ADD at home
What is attention deficit disorder?
Stenger's owner tosses in the towel
Holiday TV schedule
Ex-mayor may be headed back to council
2 new schools would use up much of bond
Addyston fire dept. closed amid questions
Arts galore offered at Miami
Boone Co. commissioner to commute out of state for job
Campbell boosts tax cap
Don't cut local inspections of nursing homes, city told
Estate true to holidays of past
Holiday fun galore in Warren Co.
Industrial cleanup agency gets boost from chamber
Jury sorting out school case
Lebanon reaches deal to swap sites for complex
Man acquitted of murder charge
Mayor replaces state rep hopeful
McCurley new mayor of Mason
Murder-suicide suspected
N.Ky. museum tweaks, delays expansion
- Sides at trial describe killing
Suspect who left hospital caught