Tuesday, August 22, 2000
New lawyer arguing for Justin
Custody decision debated
By Andrew Welsh-Huggins
The Associated Press
COLUMBUS The Ohio Supreme Court agreed Monday to allow another lawyer to argue the case of an Ohio couple involved in an adop tion dispute with a couple in Kentucky.
The court had barred the attorney of Richard and Cheryl Asente of Girard, in northeast Ohio, from appearing before justices today because the attorney had missed a filing deadline. The justices had planned to review his written arguments.
The case is the first to be argued under a new court rule speeding up custody cases to reduce the amount of time a child spends in foster care.
The court said Monday that Rosemary Pomeroy, an attorney with Grassroots Citizens for Children, a nonprofit children's advocacy group, is allowed to speak for the Ohioans.
The Asentes have asked the court to rule that Ohio has jurisdiction over their attempt to adopt 3-year-old Justin, whose biological parents in Kentucky agreed to his adoption, then changed their minds.
The Asentes, who previously adopted the boy's brother, Joseph, now 4, argue that Justin deserves a hearing to determine what's in his best interest.
For that to happen, the Supreme Court must rule that Ohio has jurisdiction. A probate court judge in Ohio has already ruled for a hearing, but Kenton Circuit Judge Patricia Summe ruled against it.
The Asentes have asked a Kentucky appeals court to overturn the Kentucky judge's ruling, which also ordered them to return the child to his biological parents, Regina Moore and Jerry Dorning, of Covington.
Just because he's being adopted, he shouldn't be treated any differently than any other child, said Samuel Totaro, a Philadelphia attorney with the American Academy of Adoption Attorneys, who filed court documents on behalf of the Asentes. If two biological parents were fighting over him for custody, there would be a best-in terest hearing.
Ms. Pomeroy also filed documents with the court supporting the Asentes' position.
The Asentes' Columbus lawyer, Charles Milless, had missed a filing deadline on May 30 by one minute.
He blamed the delay on his mother's death earlier in the month, as well as problems with a broken copy machine and the court's security equipment the day the documents were due.
Susan Garner Eisenman, who also represents the Asentes, said Monday she was pleased the court will allow Ms. Pomeroy to present the case.
Ms. Moore and Mr. Dorning could not be reached to comment on the decision. Judge Summe has banned all parties in Kentucky from discussing most aspects of the case.
Ms. Moore's attorney, Richard Cullison, has said that Ohio courts should follow the Kentucky rulings and not force the case to begin again.
The Asentes, both 37, say they are trying to make the best of a stressful situation. Richard Asente said Monday that the couple has spent more than $330,000 on legal fees, in addition to the expense of driving Justin to court-ordered visits with his biological parents in Kentucky.
He and his wife, a full-time homemaker, believe the boys would be better off together with them, the only people they recognize as parents, Mr. Asente said.
The case permeates every second of every minute of every day, said Mr. Asente, an office supply store manager.
We try to have days when we say we're not going to talk about it, but it's hard, especially on holidays. It makes you wonder if everyone will be together next year, on the next birthday, on Mother's Day.
Cincinnati schools seek 6-mill levy
School fees add up
Poet's scholarship restored
PULFER: Quiet gifts of a woman with power
Sitter indicted in child's death
Vandals strike at monuments
Would-be moviemaker wants $1M back
Accused trio return to school
FWW project may set trend
Parham, Walnut win most improved
Twin's sister receives kidney
Two jailed for animal cruelty
Christina Aguilera all grown up now
Pearl Jam lets music do talking
American Girls books get Queen City connection
GET TO IT
Pig Parade: Yellow Submarine
KNIPPENBERG: Practical jokesters return to payback
Bus plans for Monroe determined
Lucas' no-show decision lauded
New lawyer arguing for Justin
Riverfront Place wants to expand
School program shows kids importance of religion
SORTA near deal on land
Staggered terms among changes
Stine, Black among GOP campaign heads
Suspect under house arrest