Saturday, October 07, 2000
Ky. pair petition for Justin
The Cincinnati Enquirer
FRANKFORT A Northern Kentucky couple fighting for the return of their biological son, 3 1/2-year-old Justin, are asking the Kentucky Court of Appeals to reconsider a September ruling that the child can remain with the Ohio couple trying to adopt him.
Regina Moore and Jerry Dorning, an unmarried couple of Burlington, filed a petition Friday in the state appellate court for a rehearing of their case.
If it is unsuccessful, their only option is to file an appeal with the Kentucky Supreme Court. Attorneys for Ms. Moore and Mr. Dorning already have said they've given up on the possibility of getting the case into the federal court system.
Justin was born in February 1997. He went to live with Rich and Cheryl Asente of Girard, Ohio, when he was 11 months old. Ms. Moore and Mr. Dorning had signed consent-to-adopt forms, which stated that they were irrevocable after 20 days.
Ms. Moore and Mr. Dorning have said they signed the consents with the understanding that they would have until a special hearing to change their minds.
They requested Justin's return the day of that hearing, which then never took place. The Asentes refused to give Justin back, leading Ms. Moore and Mr. Dorning to sue.
Kenton Circuit Judge Patricia Summe ruled in February 1999 that the biological parents had made a misinformed decision when they let Justin go live with the Asentes. She ordered Justin's return to his biological parents.
The state appellate court reversed that decision on Sept. 15, writing in an opinion that the biological parents knew the significance of their signatures on the consents.
The Ohio Supreme Court already has decided that Kentucky has proper jurisdiction over Justin's case. The Asentes filed a motion for reconsideration, which was denied and leaves Kentucky courts with the ultimate say in Justin's case.
Newport struggles as chill moves in
Powerful water stream cut gas main 'like a drill'
Schools promote online safety
Ads for 'hell house' pulled
Extra beds barred
RAMSEY: School nutrition
Tavern in Butler Co. sold pot, crystal meth, cops say
Woman indicted in shooting death
Chabot defends fund vote
Hamilton: We can beat job loss
Almanac hints at cold snap
Antiques show offers treasures
Boy admitted to hospital after fight
Boy convicted of injuring driver
Brother is charged with slaying
Cab driver's killer sentenced to prison
County bond rating goes up
County official fears fires
DNA links baby, slain woman
Driver gets probation for causing man's death
Fall fun under way
FBI to probe behavior on flight
Firm's former VP may be part of scheme
Gallatin Steel fined $925,000
Hinton directs focus to others
Hooters asks award be cut
HOWARD: Neighborhoods
Hundreds of nuclear jobs at Piketon spared
Ky. pair petition for Justin
McNUTT: Writer's reward
No sports without reports
Robber, 19, gets 7-year sentence
Second patient dies after treatment at center
Study explains radiation victims' cancer
Suspect says uncle threatened to kill him
Toddler recovering from fall
Walkers await new path
Tristate A.M. Report