Wednesday, February 07, 2001
Hospital crunch worsens
Staff shortages and full ICUs contribute to diversion record
By Tim Bonfield
The Cincinnati Enquirer
A wave of sick elderly people and a mix of winter illnesses in January combined to shatter the previous record for ambulance diversions at Greater Cincinnati hospitals.
Eleven hospitals in Hamilton, Butler and Clermont counties went on diversion 82 times in January, according to the Greater Cincinnati Health Council.
That's a 44 percent increase over the previous record of 57 in November and about twice as many as January 2000.
A diversion means a hospital has asked life squads to take as many patients as possible somewhere else for all or part of an eight-hour shift.
The increase in diversions means it can take longer for life squads to get people to a hospital. It also means extended waits for care for walk-ins, or those with non-life-threatening problems who drove themselves or a loved one to a hospital.
The diversions are occurring for several reasons, said Colleen O'Toole, vice president of the council.
Hospitals continue to struggle to hire enough nurses and other staff to meet demand even though they are paying overtime, hiring temps and calling in managers with nursing degrees to help with patient care.
Severely ill patients are filling up limited numbers of intensive care beds, which causes back-ups in emergency departments.
Meanwhile, lots of people seem to be getting sick in lots of ways, she said.
While influenza remains lower-than-expected for this time of year, a wave of gastrointestinal illness has hit many parts of town, sometimes strongly enough to force schools to close. Meanwhile, hospitals have been especially busy treating heart attacks, strokes and pneumonia, especially among elderly people.
Most often we've had intensive care units filling up, so the emergency department ends up holding people, Ms. O'Toole said. We're seeing hospitals operating temporary ICUs in their emergency departments.
The health council tracks diversions at 14 hospitals that share emergency communication systems.
There are exceptions. For example, life squads can ignore diversion requests when they have unstable patients or when the patient insists on a particular hospital. Hospitals clustered in different parts of town also have agreed not to go on diversion all at once.
By law, hospitals cannot turn away patients who walk in to an emergency room.
In January, the hospitals with the most diversions were Jewish Hospital in Kenwood and the VA Medical Center in Corryville, each with 21; and Mercy Franciscan Mount Airy, with 11.
In Northern Kentucky, no hospitals went on diversion in January, but they've been busy.
Volumes were way up, said Karla Webb, spokeswoman for St. Elizabeth Medical Center. There were times we looked into (going on diversion). But when we needed to, we'd check with other hospitals and find there was no place for the patients to go.
With more wintry weather yet to come, hospital officials see few signs of relief.
Influenza has yet to peak in Greater Cincinnati. When it does, hospitals plan to seek approval to put flu patients in beds normally used only for rehabilitation, ambulatory surgery and other specialty services.
However, a temporary increase in bed capacity won't increase the number of nurses.
There will be more shifting around (of nurses' duties), Ms. O'Toole said. But will there be enough nurses? I can't answer that.
Hospital crunch worsens
OxyContin: Pain drug becomes the 'heroin of the Midwest'
Physician caught up in OxyContin scheme
TV's sex content climbs, study says
Deters bows out as GOP chief
Ditch the coat - for a day or 2
Brookville woman dies in collision
FBI aids in Hamilton racism
RADEL: State quarters
Village disbands its police force
AIDS fight targeting young, gay black men
CROWLEY: Bunning gunning for Greenspan
SAMPLES: Connections
Colerain buys flood-prone homes
Commandment group buys TV time
Company downsizing spawns fair for jobless
CovCath plans $7.5M home
Error puts schools in money bind
Genesis problems known for years, Heimlich says
Kenton obtains office space
Ky. Assembly has contentious first day
Ky. loses bid to reinstate death sentence against Gall
Lines form for heating program
Mason hires new fire chief
Merger of two cities questioned
Murder suspect seeks 3-judge panel for new trial
Patrons of Music Hall will get new lift
Robot project teaches Highlands students engineering
School district land swap rejected; tax hike fails again
Senate committee OKs reform bills
Suspect says killing was self-defense
Suspect's transfer blocked
Taft demands child-support flaws be fixed
Three men killed when their vehicle falls through thin ice in Lake Erie accident
Woodlawn tax boost passes; school measures elsewhere fail
Kentucky News Briefs
Tristate A.M. Report