Saturday, February 10, 2001
Vandalism follows portfolio dispute
School tells seniors to redo 4 years' work
By Lori Hayes
The Cincinnati Enquirer
ALEXANDRIA Campbell County High School was vandalized with spray-painted profanities early Friday, three days after seniors were told they would have to redo writing portfolios because of teachers' errors.
After school administrators found improper editing on students' work, Principal Stephen Sorrell confiscated all 325 seniors' portfolios and told the class Tuesday they have to start over.
A worker removes graffiti from Campbell County High School Friday.
(Patrick Reddy photo)
| ZOOM |
|
The writing portfolios, required by the Kentucky Department of Education, are due to the state in early April. That gives students about seven weeks to reproduce the portfolios, which they have worked on since ninth grade.
Nobody I know is wanting to do this again, said senior Ryan Hall, 17. He said the vandalism was an immature reaction but at least drew attention to the students' concerns.
They ripped four years of work away from us. That should be illegal.
Mr. Sorrell wouldn't elaborate on the types of errors made by teachers or whether they were a result of cheating or carelessness.
It's all being investigated, he said.
Police and school officials linked the vandalism to the students' anger over having to redo the portfolios. However, they stopped short of blaming seniors for the graffiti.
School officials said they understood the burden on the students but that state guidelines require the work to be redone.
It was a mistake by the school, not the kids, said Chris Gramke, a spokesman for the district. I understand that the students are upset, but defacing school property isn't going to change anything. There are other ways to get their voices heard.
Staff members discovered the vandalism around 6 a.m. Friday. Portfolio was written several times around the building, along with other remarks and obscenities. School officials believe the vandalism occurred between midnight and 6 a.m.
Police have no suspects. The vandals would face felony charges for criminal mischief.
Several students agreed Friday that the vandalism was uncalled for. Some student clubs donated money toward a $1,000 reward for information on who vandalized the school.
They should've just went to Mr. Sorrell instead of ruining our school, said senior Dana Rachford, 17.
State officials discovered the portfolio errors in January during a review of the high school, prompted by the school's low marks on last year's state tests.
Some teachers it's unclear how many improperly developed some of the students' portfolio work, which is restricted by the state, Mr. Gramke said.
The state has detailed guidelines for what teachers can and cannot do to help students prepare portfolio work. Portfolios that violate these guidelines are given a score of zero, which can hurt a school's test scores.
For example, teachers can mark on students' papers to point out an error but they cannot make corrections or revisions. That includes anything from inserting a comma to rewriting paragraphs.
The portfolio is to be a students' best work, not a revised version of that work, said Lisa Gross, a spokeswoman for the state Education Department.
All Campbell County teachers have been trained on portfolio procedures. All high school teachers, however, will be re-trained before the end of the school year, Mr. Gramke said.
Students fear the school will not allow them to graduate if they don't redo the work.
Although the state requires students to complete portfolios, there is no consequence for students if they do not submit one.
It's the schools that would suffer because the incomplete portfolios would be given a score of zero and would bring down overall district scores.
To prevent that, Campbell County High School requires the portfolios for graduation. However, the school council plans to review that policy in March, Mr. Sorrell said.
The school is providing class time and assistance for the students to complete the portfolios.
Patrick Stack contributed to this report.
Winburn steps down from council
Bengals looking to settle seat suit
Pharmacies jockeying for drive-through room
Winds bring damage, outages
Chamber recognizes Cincinnati fixture
Mental-health system criticized
OxyContin use said likely to spread
SAMPLES: Fright sight
UC: Thou shalt do the right thing
Boy's project: surgery
Tower owner sues Hamilton
Vets to receive honorary diplomas
Anti-profiling lawyers team up
Audit: State's foster-care programs need work
Drug raid near Highlands nets 12
Four days in February for the birds
Horse farm's concrete icon missing
HOWARD: Neighborhoods
Immigrant sentenced to 10 years in slaying
Indictments issued in nursing home deaths
Judge allows depositions in mine case
Lebanon seeks way to buy gyms
Mayor orders files held
MCNUTT: Go Bouldering
Montgomery Inn opening in Ft. Mitchell
Mt. St. Joe offers high school honors program
Princeton Pike, Mulhauser crossings due for overhaul
UK president-designate pays calls in Capitol
Vandalism follows portfolio dispute
Kentucky News Briefs
Tristate A.M. Report