Thursday, April 05, 2001
Traffic-stop data scrutinized
State releases first racial tally
By Jane Prendergast
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Almost 90 percent of the motorists stopped and issued warnings by Ohio troopers this year were white, according to statistics released Wednesday by the Ohio State Highway Patrol.
The numbers are the first glimpse at a new racial profiling information project under way by the patrol.
Troopers are recording the races of all drivers given official warnings for a traffic violation. They are continuing to record the races of drivers given citations.
Unlike programs being conducted in some cities, the patrol does not record the race of drivers who are let go without tickets or written warnings.
|
THE NUMBERS
|
Warnings issued January through March:
White: 88 percent.
Black: 9 percent.
Hispanic: 2 percent.
Asian: 1 percent.
Native American: Less than 1 percent.
|
The first-quarter data brought a mixed reaction from the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio.
As far as it goes, it's a good first step, said legal director Raymond Vasvari. But there's significant data missing here.
It's unclear, he said, how many drivers are not being counted.
From January through March, troopers wrote warnings to 75,335 drivers 88 percent of them white, 9 percent black, 2 percent Hispanic, 1 percent Asian and less than 1 percent American Indian.
Because the trooper's perception of the person's race is what's important, troopers do not ask the driver's race; they record what they think is correct.
The racial breakdown of Ohio's 11.35 million population is 85 percent white, 11.5 percent black, 1.9 percent Hispanic, 1.2 percent Asian, 1.4 percent mixed race and 0.2 percent American Indian, according to 2000 Census data.
The patrol also released its traffic citation data for all of 2000. It shows that of 721,845 drivers ticketed last year, 89 percent were white, 8 percent black, and 1 percent each were Asian, Hispanic and unknown. Native Americans made up less than 1 percent.
The highway patrol's project is much less extensive than what Cincinnati officers will start next month. They will record the race, age and sex of every driver and passenger stopped, whether the driver is given a ticket, warning, or simply let go. Cincinnati officers also will track the nature of the traffic stop, any arrests made, if the vehicle was searched and why.
Lt. Gary Lewis, spokesman for the highway patrol, defended the agency's program and results by saying only a fraction of drivers are omitted. He said the patrol did not want to count every person in contact with a trooper because that would include those who call for assistance.
We've collected the information where enforcement has been or could have been initiated, he said.
It is also difficult to determine what population to compare the drivers' race data to, Lt. Lewis said. Counting drivers on highways driven by people from all over the country is different, he said, than tracking those who might drive on a city's streets.
In Cincinnati, data collection starts May 7. The city is being sued by the ACLU and Cincinnati Black United Front, which allege that officers have discriminated for years against black citizens in traffic stops and other ways.
Lawyers on both sides of the Cincinnati suit are due back in federal court Wednesday to report on what aspects, if any, on which they think they might be able to negotiate.
Cosby the draw for UC ceremony
Cover-up by Cosco infuriates area moms
School welcomes immigrants' kids
Traffic-stop data scrutinized
Blank facade will remain on Freedom Center
Church to care for city playgrounds
Dispute growing over mold at Sharonville grade school
Zoning may stall hospital move
Butler Democrats fill vacancy
New Fairfield police station to provide extra benefits
St. Ursula unveils building
Blacks form majority of GOP slate
Campaign reform lawsuit plotted
City wants good watchdog to guard riverfront
Councilman wonders if city's getting cheated on storm water
GOP school package introduced
Grant Co. compromises on calendar
Kent State students appeal commemoration decision
Ky.'s prescription tracking system helps convict woman
Low-income tenants want church management ousted
Man accused of spending taxpayer money for porn
Man pleads not guilty in two slayings
Mount Healthy OKs new pool
Murder charge in crash raises questions
Murder charge in baby's death leaves Murray campus in 'shock'
Pair are taken off coal study panel
Proposed runway gets thumbs down on Ohio side
PULFER: McVeigh book
Rally at XU casts light on union's efforts at company
Relations award honors four
Schools offering home program
Showcase set to expand
Sloppy Joe's gives way to One Riverfront Row banquet complex
State spends thousands for worker 'humor' sessions
Student accused of firing gun in Columbus school restroom
Teacher jobs draw interest
9-year-old hit riding bicycle remains critical
Kentucky News Briefs
Tristate A.M. Report