Saturday, June 09, 2001
Plea entered in Craven killing
McIntire admits role in pilot's death
By Jim Hannah
The Cincinnati Enquirer
COVINGTON An evidence-suppression hearing in the capital murder of Delta pilot Stephen Craven took a dramatic turn Friday afternoon when one of the three co-defendants pleaded guilty.
Rusty McIntire, 33, of Erlanger, who law enforcement officials said was Adele Craven's lover, changed his plea to guilty and avoided the death penalty.
In a conditional plea agreement with state Prosecutor Luke Morgan, Mr. McIntire will cooperate in exchange for a sentence recommendation of life in prison without the possibility of parole for 25 years.
I participated in the murder of Stephen Craven, Mr. McIntire said, while sitting in shackles.
When asked by the judge if he felt uncomfortable making the statement while his two co-defendants were in the courtroom, Mr. McIntire said, Judge, the truth is the truth, and you can't hide the truth from anyone.
The co-defendants are Mrs. Craven Mr. McIntire's reputed lover and wife of the murdered pilot and Ronald Pryor, a former car washer from Independence, whom investigators say was hired as a hit man.
Mr. Craven, who was beaten and shot, was found dead in the basement of his Edgewood home last July.
Kenton Circuit Judge Patricia Summe called the guilty plea somewhat of a surprise. She found out about the plea agreement hours before the 1 p.m. hearing. The state attorney general's staff said that office was informed of the change of plea at 10:30 p.m. Thursday.
Judge Summe said she understood that Mr. McIntire relied on advice from his father when making decisions. Mr. McIntire's father, also named Russell, was at the hearing but declined to answer questions from reporters.
He (Rusty McIntire) is very close to his family and didn't want to put them through the stress of a death penalty case, said Mr. McIntire's attorney, Rodney D. Barnes.
Mr. Barnes, a public defender from the Department of Public Advocacy in Frankfort, became a co-counsel for Mr. McIntire about three weeks ago. Judge Summe said it was her understanding that Mr. McIntire had had a disagreement with his original attorney, Jon Alig of Covington. Mr. Alig left court before the hearing was over and could not be reached for comment.
According to Mr. Barnes, his client didn't actively commit a murder but was complicitous to a murder. Police have testified that Mr. McIntire helped recruit former co-worker Mr. Pryor to kill Mr. Craven for $1,000 and the promise of $14,000 more.
Mr. McIntire's cooperation with investigators helped break the case, police said.
As part of the agreement, Mr. McIntire will be moved from the Kenton County Jail to another jail to await sentencing. Mr. McIntire, Mrs. Craven and Mr. Pryor are all being held at the Kenton County Jail. The elder Mr. McIntire has agreed to pay any additional costs associated with incarcerating his son outside the county.
Sentencing for Mr. McIntire is scheduled for November, after the trials of Mrs. Craven and Mr. Pryor. Their murder trial is scheduled to begin in October. It is unclear whether the two will be tried together. The judge has ruled that each will be tried separately, but the prosecutor told the court late Friday that he intends to file a motion to try both cases together.
Rebecca Lytle, a Frankfort public defender who represents Mr. Pryor, said she wasn't surprised by the guilty plea. She wouldn't comment when asked how the plea might affect her case.
Mrs. Craven's attorney, Deanna Dennison of Covington, said she will know better how her case is going when the judge rules on her motion to suppress evidence gathered at the crime scene. The hearing on the motion to suppress is to be concluded June 22.
We are really pleased in the guilty plea, said Stephen Craven's brother, Bill, 43, of Atlanta. We are extremely pleased with the work of (Kenton County Police) Detective Wayne Wallace and prosecutor Luke Morgan.
Bill Craven, 43, traveled to Covington with his mother to attend the hearing. He has custody of the Cravens' two sons.
I think there is a lot of evidence yet to be heard that is very powerful, Bill Craven said.
A typed statement that detailed Mr. McIntire's involvement in the murder was sealed by Judge Summe, who said it could hamper jury selection.
UC grads challenged to improve city
May showers bring ... mosquitoes
Fans in frenzy over 'NSync
Game's future may be in doubt
Gay pride leaders say support up
Lawmakers make annexation harder
Now students can live at school
Ohio birthday budget shrinks
Rally turns focus to growing violence
MCNUTT: Canine fun
Plea entered in Craven killing
Fliers show off stunts
Community center hunts for funds
Company will compensate landowners when laying cable
County rule applies to city
Dayton faces civil rights lawsuit
DEA moving to monitor OxyContin
Form of meningitis kills Toledo teacher
Girl killed, two hurt in crash
Injured man identified
Killer's plea: third execution countdown cruel
Man guilty in child porn case
Ohio family of four found shot to death
Parents, too, taste college life
Patton: Budget will be OK in '02
Police look for foiled hotel robber
Racketeering charges a first
Siblings charged after cats found in squalor
Thermal camera shows suspect in dark
Thousands near Salem get shots
Uncapped tuition expected to leap
Kentucky News Briefs
Tristate A.M. Report