Wednesday, August 1, 2001
20 years of MTV: The hits, the misses
Readers recount the highs and lows
in music channel's history
By Erin Kosnac
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Out of a small studio in New Jersey, MTV launched its first
music video in 1981: the Buggles' "Video Killed the Radio Star."
Out of a studio in Times Square, 'NSync and the Backstreet Boys
jockey for the top position on MTV's Total Request Live (TRL). show
title
From the Buggles to the Backstreet Boys, there have been some
memorable videos have aired on MTV: Michael Jackson's "Thriller,"
Nirvana's "Smells Like Teen Spirit" and Guns N' Roses "November
Rain," are three among many.
To help celebrate MTV's 20th birthday we asked what you thought
were the best - and the worst - music videos. Here's what you said:
World premiere
I still vividly remember sitting on the brown and green
plaid couches in our basement with my older brother Jim, sipping
Cokes and waiting with excited anticipation for the world premiere of
David Bowie's "Let's Dance."
MTV had been promoting the new release for weeks, and being kids
of the '80s, we were enthralled by this new invention of music
videos. David Bowie and MTV did not let us down.
The rhythmic beat of the bass repeating with the refrain "Let's
dance. Put on your red shoes and dance the blues" pulsed through our
teen-age veins.
The contrast of the third-world country depicted in the video
images with the scarlet pair of pumps the heroine wore was confusing,
symbolic and thought-provoking. And, the rock icon David Bowie again
wowed audiences with his latest and greatest persona.
This time his shocking bleached-blond hair and pale suit depicted
a strikingly handsome gentleman far from the glitter rock lord of
Ziggy Stardust, but equally, if not more, captivating.
- Laura L. Smith, 32, Oxford
Brotherly love
| WATCH THE VIDEO
|
"If Only"
Artist: Hanson
|
My vote for best music video in MTV history would have to go
to Hanson's "If Only." I feel that video portrays exactly what a
summer rock 'n' roll video should look like. Not to mention the song
is a fan favorite. That video went to No. 1 27 times on MTV's TRL
title of show. I've been a fan of Hanson since 1997, and every video
of theirs is great, but "If Only" is my fave.
My vote for worst video would have to go to 'NSync's "I Drive
Myself Crazy." I mean nobody is going to take a band seriously if
they are standing in silk pajamas in a mental institute singing about
teeny-bopper breakups. Why can't 'NSync just learn to play some
instruments and not be so cheesy? Justin (Timberlake) needs to tell
his girlfriend Britney (Spears) to put some clothes on, as well.
- Sarah Dwyer, 14, Fairfield
Use your imagination
With the minimalist usage of burning candles set atop 100
6-foot candle holders, flickering languidly before a darkened
backdrop, the Police's "Wrapped Around Your Finger" music video
allows the viewer to fill in the blanks with their imagination.
Lyrics like "I can see the destiny you sold turned into a shining
band of gold," evoke a zen-like coda that, like the life of one
candle, is both here and gone.
- Kurt Hultquist, 45, Elmwood Place
So good, so bad
Paul Simon's "You Can Call Me Al" with Chevy Chase is
everything a music video should be: simple, direct, doesn't interpret
the lyrics or tell some story.
The Rolling Stones "Start Me Up" was so bad it was great. When
Bill Wyman mischievously looks over at Charlie Watts and snickers
then shakes his head, it's a classic video moment. Also enjoyable was
how (Mick) Jagger could not sing in sync with the backing track. This
is a video gem for all the wrong reasons. But like a train wreck, it
is always interesting - and fun - to watch.
- Bob Theissen, 47, Covington
Lionel vs. Eminem
My favorite video of all is Lionel Richie's "All Night
Long." Everyone seems happy and joyful, and little kids are dancing
in the street.
The set of the video is brightly lit and seems to be taking place
in a far-off exotic world - a Shangri-la.
Whenever I see this video, it lifts my spirit. Although, I never
see it being played much anymore.
My least favorite video is Eminem's "Real Slim Shady." A whole
bunch of blond Eminem look-alikes gives a zombie-like effect to the
video. I think the worst thing that I've ever seen in any video is
when the fast-food worker spits in the customer's food before serving
the order.
- Charles Michel, 48, Price Hill
Piece of Cake
I really like Cake's new video ("Short Skirt/Long Jacket")
where people are listening to the song and saying what they think
about it. It's just funny, and it's a good song. It does really look
like they picked real people instead of just staging something. It
goes along really well, too, with the reality-based thing like
Blink-182 just did in (its) new video ("Rock Show").
- Jeff Warshaw, 17, Blue Ash
Strike a pose
My favorite video wasn't really a video but a performance on
the Video Music Awards. It was when Madonna performed "Vogue" in
Elizabethan style. She had all these wigs, all these costumes. It was
awesome. It was just so different. You could totally tell she was lip
syncing, but it didn't matter because the performance and costumes
and what she was doing onstage just grabbed your attention.
My least favorite video right now would have to be any video with
half-naked women. It's like come on, can't we come up with something
different? I've already watched this with Motley Crue and Cinderella,
and now all the rappers are doing it. There's half-naked chicks on
cars and motorcycles. Really, can't we be a little more creative?
- Chloe Franklin, 21, Golf Manor
Good old days
I really liked "Children's Story" by Slick Rick. It
reminds me of my high school days back in 1990, around the time when
I was playing high school football. It brings all those memories
back. I had a mullet, long hair. The girls hated me. They still do.
Maybe it hasn't all changed.
- Kris Klepper, 27, Oakley
How 20 years of MTV changed so much
20 years of MTV: The hits, the misses
How 20 years of MTV changed so much
Sweet-singing baby James charms Riverbend
Clean up shigellosis outbreak
Body and Mind
Few changes cut fat in peachy cheesecake
Smart mouth
Get to It