A panel of architects that has privately reviewed plans for several major downtown Cincinnati projects — including the new Bengals and Reds stadiums — must meet in public.

        An appeals court judge Friday rejected the city's argument that the Urban Design Review Board acts as a consultant for the city manager and should be allowed to meet privately.

        “There is no merit to the city's contention that the (board) does not advise a public body,” said Judge Mark Painter of the Ohio First District Court of Appeals. “It clearly follows that all meetings of the UDRB must be public meetings open to the public.”

        The decision followed a Cincinnati Enquirer lawsuit last year after its reporters were denied access to meetings about the Reds' new stadium.

        “We just got the decision,” Deputy City Solicitor Pete Heile said Friday. “We're looking at it, and we will discuss it with the city manager to decide what steps may be appropriate.”

        City Manager John Shirey did not return phone calls.

        Friday's ruling upholds a December decision in Hamilton County Common Pleas Court, which found the board not only advises the city manager but also makes decisions and recommendations to council.

        The board comprises four architects who review project designs on sites sold or leased by the city in the central business district and central riverfront.

        Its approval is required before the city commits funds.

Ticketing shortfall pinches budget
Winning big isn't ticket to paradise
Adding 75 police slots proposed
Bargains abound at Sayler Park
South Cumminsville blooms anew
Council clerk clocks out
Football team scores uniforms
Private school debut delayed
Urban board has to meet in the open
$100K is OK with 5-number lottery winner
Fest shows musical taste
HOWARD: Neighborhoods
MCNUTT: Warren County
Norwood officer up for hearing
Tristate A.M. Report
UC pay offer: Merit but no across-the-board
City cable to air political ads
Commandments stay for now
Pilot dies in plane crash
Suspect says he killed 6
Two arrested in boy's fatal BB shooting
Baby's mother comes forward
Covington police chief to retire
EKU names woman president
Keating disbarred in Ky.
Ky. man shoots wife, kills self
Latonia groups converge at intersection to honor Korean War veterans
Meetings to detail water system sale
N. Ky. GOP searching for accord