Saturday, September 08, 2001
Dispute over lot may cost suburb
Weeds, case, costs grew out of control
By John Nolan
The Associated Press
A dispute between two neighbors over the high grass and vines on a vacant lot became a seven-year court battle that now could cost a Cleveland suburb at least $250,000 in attorneys' fees.
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday ordered a lower court to determine how much Mayfield Heights should pay resident Sanford J. Berger, who won his lawsuit against a city order to cut the grass and weeds.
Mr. Berger's lawyer, Bruce Elfvin, said the fees will total at least $250,000 and could go as high as $270,000. L. Bryan Carr, a lawyer for Mayfield Heights, said he will argue when the case goes back before U.S. District Judge David Katz that the city owes Mr. Berger nothing.
But appeals Judges Martha Craig Daughtrey, Alan Norris and Lawrence Zatkoff said Mr. Berger is entitled to the money because he won the suit.
The vacant, wooded lot is next door to Mr. Berger's house. For the past 20 years he has kept the lot in a natural state with trees, fallen trees, vines, grass and weeds.
Lendell Riddle, a neighbor since 1991, complained to the city that Mr. Berger should cut the grass, weeds and vines. In 1992, the City Council amended a 35-year-old ordinance to require that nox ious or poisonous weeds or vines be cut to a height of 8 inches or less on any lot having a street frontage of 100 feet or less.
Mr. Berger said the amendment was intended to single him out, and he refused to comply. After the city cited him for a criminal violation, Mr. Berger sued in 1994, alleging that the amendment violated his constitutional rights of due process and equal protection of law.
The city's lawyers said the ordinance would have applied to a half dozen vacant lots and was meant to safeguard public health and welfare.
Saving My Gal Sal
Taft searches for school funds
Decision means Ohio to pay millions more
Candidates hash it out
Bells come to towns
DeWine, Pepper lead fund-raising
Priest guided future XU president
Child support scofflaw ordered to prison
Teen-ager recovering from lightning strike
Tristate A.M. Report
Turpin High apologizes for slurs
HOWARD: Neighborhoods
MCNUTT: Warren County
Ballot suit thrown out
Board seeks leader widely
Diversity goes suburban
Hamilton man sues Bayer over medicine
Yorkies and owners strutting their stuff
Dispute over lot may cost suburb
Shooting suspect, 84, ends standoff
Traficant claims he has secret evidence
AIDS' spread among blacks raises flags
Budget cuts hit schools, welfare
Circus mix: thrills, animals, nostalgia
Kentucky News Briefs
Ky. doctor accused of over-prescribing Oxy
Meth labs broken up; 3 charged
Nunn joins a full field
Patton defends office payroll
Photographer didn't stay grounded
Son succeeds dad as Murray State head