Saturday, October 20, 2001
Witness: Fantasy could turn real
Sex offender tries to withdraw plea, challenge Ohio law
By Liz Sidoti
The Associated Press
COLUMBUS A social worker testified Friday that a man imprisoned for writing fantasies in his journal about torturing and molesting children could potentially act on those thoughts.
Robin Aurnou was a witness for prosecutors who are arguing against allowing Brian Dalton to withdraw his guilty plea so he can fight the constitutionality of state law.
Mr. Dalton, 22, pleaded guilty in July to pandering obscenity involving a minor, Ohio's child-pornography law.
The case has alarmed lawyers specializing in First Amendment and obscenity law, who think Mr. Dalton is the first person in the United States successfully prosecuted for child pornography that involved writings, not images.
Ms. Aurnou diagnosed Mr. Dalton as a pedophile in January 2000, when she worked at a treatment program that he was required to attend after a 1998 pandering conviction involving pornographic photographs of children.
She testified that her diagnosis revealed a high risk that Mr. Dalton would act on his fantasies and that his private journals could trigger him to do so.
She also said an increase in the frequency and severity of his fantasies written in this journal and a journal from several years ago makes it more likely that Mr. Dalton would act on them.
Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Nodine Miller twice refused defense requests to strike Ms. Aurnou's testimony. Mr. Dalton's attorneys said the testimony had nothing to do with their argument that his plea and 10-year sentence should be thrown out because of ineffective counsel from his former attorney Isabella Dixon.
Her testimony in no way deals with the failures of Ms. Dixon, said Benson Wolman, the lead attorney on Mr. Dalton's defense team, made up of lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union.
They have asked Judge Miller to reconsider her refusal to allow Mr. Dalton to withdraw his plea. Judge Miller did not say when she will rule.
Scott Forehand, an assistant prosecutor, said the social worker's testimony was relevant because of the defense's underlying reason for wanting to withdraw the guilty plea to fight the constitutionality of the child pornography law.
This witness showed that these materials would be made much more dangerous in his hands, and that would make them (the written words) fall under the law, Mr. Forehand said.
Apology follows offer to hijack victims' families
Concrete cracking at stadium
Agencies sweat out fund drive
Flyboys keep My Gal Sal in their hearts
Officials ask God for guidance at Red Mass
Police can air ideas in private
Police investigate 3 bank robberies
Tristate A.M. Report
UC loses $11.2M from subsidy
MCNUTT: Warren County Witches' persecution examined
SAMPLES: Displays oddly comforting
Court may reconsider school funding
Sheppard family won't auction handkerchiefs
Spiff up your state Web sites, political parties advised
Tugs can't free freighter
Witness: Fantasy could turn real
Best bands show off brass
Industry reps miss meeting on mining rules
Kenton Co. considers more security
Kentucky News Briefs
New rail link boosts readiness at post
Outdoor education area for blind, disabled
Schools's garden is growing peace