Saturday, November 10, 2001
Byrd defender asks out of case
By James Hannah
Associated Press Writer
DAYTON The state public defender on Friday withdrew as counsel in a federal court hearing for a man facing execution for a slaying he denies, raising questions about his office's future role in the case.
Ohio Public Defender David Bodiker asked U.S. Magistrate Michael Merz to allow himself and his team of lawyers to withdraw as counsel for John W. Byrd Jr. Testimony in the hearing on whether Mr. Byrd is innocent of killing Colerain Township convenience-store clerk Monte Tewksbury in 1983 wrapped up Friday.
The move followed disclosures that Mr. Bodiker's office earlier failed to reveal several sworn statements from another inmate who says he committed the crime.
This case has become focused not on John Byrd's innocence, but the conduct of his lawyers, Mr. Bodiker told Mr. Merz. By our actions, we have dug a hole and pulled John Byrd down into it.
Mr. Merz said only that Mr. Bodiker could step aside and that other public defenders must continue to represent Mr. Byrd.
A federal appeals court postponed Mr. Byrd's execution in September to allow for Mr. Merz to hear his claims of innocence.
Prosecutor James Canepa of the Ohio attorney general's office said if the public defender's office were allowed to step aside, new attorneys would have had to have been appointed, effectively delaying Mr. Byrd's execution.
The impact would be to pull the plug on the proceedings and start at square one, Mr. Canepa said.
A man who was with Mr. Byrd at the convenience store the night of the slaying, John Brewer, has confessed to killing Mr. Tewksbury.
Prosecutors say Mr. Brewer, who also was convicted of murder in the slaying and cannot be tried again, is only trying to spare his friend's life.
At least five affidavits have been taken from Mr. Brewer. Two of the statements were disclosed earlier this year, and three were revealed during the hearing this week.
Mr. Merz will recommend to the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati whether Mr. Byrd's claim is legitimate, with the deadline Nov. 30.
Bengals' turf battle with county not over
PULFER: Do the Bengals hate us?
Parking plentiful for football, concert
Convention center plan scaled back
Mom arrested in kidnapping
'Over-vote' ballots not counted
Police may face federal charges in deaths
Added significance for Veterans Day
Kentucky events honoring veterans
Ohio events honoring vets
McNUTT: Veterans deserve our thank-yous
Veterans Day closings
Byrd defender asks out of case
Drug ads use language to make point
Local Digest
West Chester holds annual celebration
Beechmont Mall put up for sale
Bush orders more Guard to airports
Chabot to join U.N. delegation
Congrats
Evil never wins, diplomat says
Jury acquits teacher of theft
Kids OK after close call in fire
Lucas hails postal workers
SAMPLES: Things go right in one little world
Bus garage burglarized
Children see tools of war, talk to veteran
Kentucky Digest
Officials hope to launch Ky. bus tours
Kentucky picks first inductees into Music Hall
Molloy promises change
Commissioner charged in fight
Humans lead rare birds on how-to migration
Ohio to check money transfers
Traficant pleads innocent to revised federal charges
Vouchers likened to college grants