Saturday, December 01, 2001
County gets a nudge on Banks project
Firstar, PNC would back bond payments
By Dan Klepal
The Cincinnati Enquirer
Two banking companies are willing to put their financial muscle behind the $600 million riverfront development project known as The Banks so that construction is not delayed.
Firstar and PNC banks say they will guarantee payment on a series of three bond issues that will allow construction of $68 million in parking garages to start in 2003.
The commitment is significant because Hamilton County is responsible for building the garages. County leaders said the county is unable to finance construction now because sales tax revenues have come in far below expectation.
County officials said construction wouldn't begin until sales tax revenues returned to normal. A portion of the sales tax revenues would be used to pay for construction of the parking garages and the interest on the financing.
The plan was presented to the county by the Port of Greater Cincinnati Development Authority, which was created by the county to oversee riverfront development beyond the new stadiums.
Under the proposal, either the Port Authority or the county would issue 20-year, tax-free bonds in 2003 for $11 million; in 2005 for $18 million and in 2006 for $9 million. In addition, the proposal calls for the Ohio Department of Transportation to provide $30 million in loans over the same period.
Firstar and PNC say they would cover debt payments on the bonds if the county cannot. Firstar would be the lead bank and has committed to the project; negotiations are still being finalized with PNC.
The county still would be ultimately responsible for the cost of building the garages, but its credit rating wouldn't be at risk if sales tax revenues are not sufficient to make payments on the debt in any given year.
A commitment to guarantee any shortfall for such an extended period of time without major fees associated with it is very unusual, said Louie George, a Port Authority board member.
The risk is that the financial institutions don't know when they would have to give their money to cover a shortfall, and they don't know when they'll get it back, Mr. George said. They have, through civic commitment, decided to absorb that risk.
In addition, the county would use residual cash from the sales tax to pay debt on the parking garages meaning debt on The Banks garages is only paid after the county has paid debt service on stadium bonds, the property tax rollback and its contribution to Cincinnati Public Schools.
Even then, only 85 percent of that residual revenue would be used to pay off the development's parking garages. The remaining 15 percent would be held by the county to pay off early the bonds issued during construction of the stadiums.
County officials were given the proposal Thursday and said they need about a week to consider it. But County Administrator Dave Krings said the proposal is, at least, a step in the right direction.
It's better than the last (idea for interim financing), which really amounted to a general obligation to the county, Mr. Krings said. It doesn't appear this one represents that.
It is unclear how much interest the county would have to pay, if the financial institutions had to cover payments for the government.
Jack Rouse, chairman of the Port Authority, said all of that would be negotiated later. The main thing, Mr. Rouse said, is that this plan resolves all the concerns raised by the county.
The concept was that the financial institutions would be actually the ones at risk in all of this, and nothing beyond that half-percent sales tax would ever be involved, Mr. Rouse said. If we wait, we'll miss an opportunity and confirm to developers that we just don't seem to get things done around here.
The plan doesn't address all of Commissioner Todd Portune's concerns.
Mr. Portune has been working with Port Authority members for months to come up with an alternative financing plan. He still wants, among other things, a renegotiation of the Bengals lease at Paul Brown Stadium and more money from the state to free up millions of tax dollars for other riverfront development.
This does not risk the county's general fund, but it likely only adds considerable length to the time of the tax, Mr. Portune said. There are a number of uncertainties with the plan.
Still, Mr. Portune believes the county has a responsibility to define its plan for moving the development forward.
It's important to keep the ball moving, given the fact that taxpayers have $1 billion at stake on the riverfront already, Mr. Portune said. We need to articulate a clear proposal that moves the project ahead in a way that is fiscally responsible.
County gets a nudge on Banks project
Mother says she shot to stop child molester
Fans gently weep for Harrison
Beatles' guitarist influenced generations
Frampton recalls sharing music with former Beatle
Witness recounts Wehrung talk
College unveils new name, logo
Hopes high for new city political era
House OKs $2M for bridge study
Hunting season coming to end
Ind. Christmas train a hit
Jews to share stories in Israel
NAACP's Bond stresses need to fight racism
New ways of worship mean survival
Schools may be replaced
Successful program expands
Traffic helicopters no longer grounded
Tristate A.M. Report
MCNUTT: Warren County
SAMPLES: Meeting goals
THOMPSON: Jewelry for a cause
Butler looks at tax
Indictment made in kidnap case
Lebanon manager bows out
Officer of year selected
Teen hurdles onto cola label
Witness: Accused has mental troubles
Woman to serve 25 days in jail
Speaker drops demand for two-day tax break
Bill lets TANK add 6 new buses
D. Bunning will have day before panel
Defeat won't diminish fans' football season
Kentucky News Briefs
Push on to add family courts
State waives tuition for adopted kids
U of L suspends TKE fraternity
Women's Crisis Center giving gifts to residents