Tuesday, December 04, 2001
Testimony rebuts insanity plea
Doctor points to personality disorder
By Sheila McLaughlin
The Cincinnati Enquirer
LEBANON From diagnoses of schizophrenia and paranoia to psychosis and fraud, doctors for 11 years have differed in their opinions about killer Timothy Hancock.
On Monday, a psychiatrist for a prosecution team trying to block Mr. Hancock's insanity plea and send him to death row offered yet another view during the final day of testimony in Mr. Hancock's murder trial. The jury is expected to begin deliberations today.
Dr. Douglas Lehrer told a jury that Mr. Hancock has mental problems, but was not insane when he strangled child molester Jason Wagner Nov. 13, 2000, in the cell they shared at the Warren Correctional Institution.
He described Mr. Hancock as an impulsive, deceitful man who was incapable of showing remorse and was emotionally unstable. Those traits were more consis tent with personality disorders, Dr. Lehrer said, even though a prison psychologist days before the killing had diagnosed Mr. Hancock as psychotic.
But Dr. Lehrer contended that Mr. Hancock had exaggerated his symptoms through the years and duped other prison doctors into believing he was suffering from serious mental illness.
That opinion, he said, was supported by prison records that showed that treatment teams at Oakwood Correctional Facility, the state's psychiatric hospital for inmates in Lima, had discharged
Mr. Hancock back to prison four times betweenbecause they thought he was faking.
However, a psychiatrist for the defense testified last week that Mr. Hancock suffered from a delusional disorder and was insane.
Dr. Lehrer said he interviewed Mr. Hancock for four hours over a two-day period. The account was similar to the first of two statements Mr. Hancock gave to investigators.
Mr. Hancock talked about messages from an imaginary friend and from God to kill Mr. Wagner after Mr. Wagner described abducting and molesting a 3-year-old Lancaster girl in 1999, made a sexual overtures, and touched Mr. Hancock's leg, Dr. Lehrer said.
Mayor boots Rev. Lynch from race commission
Text of Lynch's response
Text of Black United Front letter
Israel bombing victim was student here
Parents seek help in sex case
How to protect your kids from sexual abuse
Ted Gregory visitation today
Unknown boy seen trailing Patty
Case tests college admission policies
'Equal funding' approved for city schools
Family finds biracial adoption a blessing
Meeting to consider county plan
Possible witnesses to shooting sought
Proposal cuts funds for biomedical research
PULFER: Tough talk about war, reputation
Sycamore day celebrates Kwanzaa fest
Congrats
Golfers on a roll as fall lingers
Good News: Program for kids in need
Local Digest
Mason-Montgomery to reopen
Two Miami students die in crash
New Lebanon council feels its way
Nonprofit to help farmers' business
Store relies on free labor
Testimony rebuts insanity plea
Fairfield waits on bus allocation
Kentucky Digest
New recreation sites entertained
Politician's re-election bid begins
Care program battles fund cuts
Frankfort woman delivers quintuplets
Horse, tobacco sales hit farm economy