Tuesday, February 12, 2002
Ambulance crash attracts scrutiny
By Janice Morse
The Cincinnati Enquirer
HAMILTON A lights-and-sirens ambulance run that ended with a wreck is being examined because the squad was carrying a patient who apparently had been dead for hours.
Police and fire officials on Monday said they were looking into the Saturday incident involving Darrell R. Smith, 45.
Officer Brian Robinson, who was trying to determine whether to cite anyone in connection with Mr. Smith's death, conferred with Butler County Coroner Dr. Richard P. Burkhardt on Monday. Then Officer Robinson filed an accident report addendum that says: In the coroner's professional opinion, Mr. Smith had died several hours before the squad responded and began transport.
The report also says Mr. Smith was undergoing cardiopulmonary resuscitation when the crash occurred.
Dr. Burkhardt noted that doctors at Fort Hamilton Hospital registered Mr. Smith's body temperature at 90.7 degrees shortly after the crash. That drop of nearly 8 degrees would take several hours, given that Mr. Smith was inside a home when found not out in the cold, Dr. Burkhardt said.
The coroner ruled that Mr. Smith died from blood clots in the lungs.
Dr. Burkhardt declined to say whether he thought it was appropriate for paramedics to transport Mr. Smith in an ambulance with lights and sirens activated.
Steve Dawson, deputy fire chief, said: Why would we transport a dead body? The only thing I can say to that is, you have a 45-year-old victim, and apparently the medics saw something there that (suggested) the victim was viable. ... We don't know all of the circumstances of what the paramedics saw.
Mr. Dawson said he expected fire department officials to review the run, but he doubted there would be a formal investigation.
In a number of seemingly hopeless cases, life support has succeeded, he said.
Special senior takes the court tonight
R&B legend Smokey Robinson to boycott
PULFER: Losing Cosby
RADEL: Civil War research
Some Good News
WELLS: Showing the flag
Air fares rebound along with demand
Fox blasts 'knucklehead' referendum drive
Ohio puts wager on Big Game
Slain woman feared harm from husband
Tight time line to settle racial profiling suit
Alum's return is a homecoming
Boehner officially in race
Shooting range has folks up in arms
Steroid charge reduced
Avondale off-duty patrols nearer
Byrd appeals to U.S. high court
Killer's fate debated
Mardi Gras '02 praised
Ambulance crash attracts scrutiny
Company to create up to 50 high-tech jobs
Constructing new future
CPS planning college prep high school
Enron seen as a spur for reform
Group opposes gambling bill
Kids find comfort in military books
Local retailers, customers see dollar signs in the Big Game
School survey data debated
Sewer deal may hit $1B
Shift seen to annexing hospital site
Sorrento owner must go to court
Tristate report
Upgrades will delay openings