Wednesday, February 13, 2002
Nurse faces 90 days in cyclist's death
Blames narcolepsy for driving off road
By Sheila McLaughlin
The Cincinnati Enquirer
FRANKLIN A Trenton nurse who is said to suffer from a disorder that causes him to drop off to sleep without warning pleaded no contest Tuesday to a reduced charge in the death of a 15-year-old bicyclist.
Daryl Ohair, 35, faces up to 90 days in jail when he is sentenced in Franklin Municipal Court in about a month on a misdemeanor charge of vehicular manslaughter.
He told police he believes he fell asleep at the wheel when he drove onto the shoulder of westbound Ohio 73 near Baxter Drive on Nov. 6 and struck James R. Jay Brinegar, a vocational-school student from Franklin who was on his way to a skating arena with a friend.
Defense attorney Christopher Atkins said he negotiated with the city prosecutor to reduce the offense from vehicular homicide after doctors diagnosed Mr. Ohair with narcolepsy. The neurological disorder is marked by uncontrollable sleep attacks and loss of muscle control.
A charge of vehicular homicide does not apply because it requires a defendant to be criminally negligent, Mr. Atkins said.
What caused the offense was him falling asleep, Mr. Atkins said.
In making the no-contest plea, Mr. Ohair admitted that the facts of the criminal complaint are true, but he did not admit guilt.
Mr. Ohair, a licensed practical nurse who was working full time and taking college courses toward a registered-nursing certificate at the time of the accident, is now taking medication to control his narcolepsy, Mr. Atkins said.
His client faced up to six months in jail, a $1,000 fine and a license suspension of one to five years if convicted of vehicular homicide, which is a higher-level misdemeanor.
Jay Brinegar's relatives, who sat quietly in the courtroom with an attorney, said they were upset the charge was reduced and that Mr. Ohair continues to drive.
Granted, he has a personal life sentence he has to live with that he killed a 15-year-old boy, said Terry Fleenor, an uncle from West Carrollton. But there is nothing that really could be considered equal.
Luken won't parley with promoters of boycott
After years, Justin adoption case could be near conclusion
Timeline of Justin case
Churches ready for start of Lent
E-mail to Cranley creates stir
German's search leads to family
Hamilton County jail goes retro with striped jumpsuits
Loveland historic property on selling block
Nurse faces 90 days in cyclist's death
Police abuse called unchanged
Rev. Heet, Roger Bacon athletic director for 33 years, dies
Snowboarding interest all uphill
Tristate A.M. Report
Waldvogel Viaduct overhaul proposed
BRONSON: Opinion drawer
HOWARD: Some Good News
SAMPLES: Shelter on way
SMITH AMOS: Hip hop healing
Group outlines Fairfield's future
Lebanon accepts reports on water, sewer
Middletown teachers get wage boost
Residents weigh in on Wharf at Symmes
Coalition unhappy over school funding talks
Expanded gaming on agenda
Ohio board seeks changes in charter school laws
Taft picks Columbus woman as running mate
Complex plans on upscale units
Merger studied (yawn) really?