Friday, March 08, 2002
Roach referendum illegal, Evendale told
By Jennifer Edwards, jedwards@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer
EVENDALE Village officials have received a second legal opinion that says administrative actions such as the hiring of Police Officer Stephen Roach are not subject to referendum votes.
Mayor Douglas Lohmeier received the opinion this week from a Dayton attorney.
Attorney John C. Chambers wrote in a March 5 letter to the mayor that referendum petitions filed with the village on the Roach hiring violate state law and Evendale's charter.
The Constitution and Charter limit referendum power to questions of a legislative nature, the letter said. The topic of the referred Ordinance, being that of hiring a specific individual, is not legislative in nature, and therefore not subject to referendum.
With the second legal opinion, it does not appear likely the hiring will go to public vote this fall.
The village solicitor, Christian Schaefer, already has told council members administrative matters are not subject to referendum.
Opponents of Officer Roach's hiring collected enough valid signatures to put their referendum to oust the officer to a vote and believe they are legally entitled to one. The Hamilton County Board of Elections checked the more than 200 names and determined at least 155 the required number were valid.
We fully expect council to certify and validate the petition to the Hamilton County Board of Elections, Dr. Thomas Shockley, an organizer of the opponents, told council members Thursday.
Mr. Schaefer says he expects the issue will wind up in court.
It's a contentious issue and someone will no doubt litigate it at some point, he said.
Officer Roach, 27, whose fatal shooting of an unarmed, fleeing man in Over-the-Rhine April 7 sparked riots, quit the Cincinnati force in January and started with Evendale Jan. 22. He was acquitted of negligent homicide and obstructing official business last fall.
Woodlawn council members recently passed a resolution voicing concern over Officer Roach's hiring because he may be on duty in Woodlawn under their mutual aid agreement with Evendale.
Officer Roach's recent experience may cause him to be overly sensitive and hesitant to react in an emergency, creating a danger to himself, fellow officers and citizens, the ordinance says.
Mayor Lohmeier and Police Chief Gary Foust declined comment on the Woodlawn resolution.
In search of remedies for rollovers
Scam victims find they're on their own
Sponsorless, Jazz Fest may be history
Bristol's dancers have day in court
Hidden war was just below
Ohio lawmakers question tax
City asked for $15.4M to assist home plan
Firefighters get firmed up
Local lawyer defends land-use handbook
Roach referendum illegal, Evendale told
St. Bernard OKs plan for park
Tristate A.M. Report
BRONSON: Court battle
HOWARD: Some Good News
SMITH AMOS: Prevention
WELLS: Truth in begging
Designation sought for 1862 house
Economic director is familiar face
Lower speeds sought for Ohio 4
School finalists to take questions
Troupe spreads the good word
Unity is crucial, Warren planners told
Vets' group leads museum fund drive
Woman pleads guilty
GOP fires early shots at Lucas
I-275 exit gets a new number
Kentucky News Briefs
Schools stay a priority in state budget
Senate panel studies power plant bill
Six accused of skirting gun permit law
Teen pen pals hear war tales