Wednesday, April 03, 2002
Girl's trial may be first under new law
By Marie McCain, mmccain@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer
A 14-year-old Avondale girl, accused of killing her father by throwing bleach on him in the heat of an argument, could become the first child in Ohio to stand trial before a Juvenile Court jury.
On Tuesday, Hamilton County Juvenile Judge Sylvia Sieve Hendon decided the girl will be tried in juvenile court, rather than adult court.
She also ordered the teen classified as a serious youthful offender.
A state law that took effect in January allows juvenile judges to order the classification, which gives the child the right to have her case heard by a jury. At least 14 other states allow juvenile jury trials.
The girl is not being named because of her age.
The 14-year-old faces juvenile counts of involuntary manslaughter and felonious assault. She is accused of throwing bleach on her 39-year-old father, Archie Dale Hall, during an argument Jan. 28 in the Northern Avenue home she shared with her grandfather, mother and other relatives.
Mr. Hall died Feb. 18 as a result of bleach inhalation.
The girl's public defender, David Montgomery, told Judge Hendon Tuesday that his client wants the case forwarded to a grand jury another provision of the new law.
If the girl is indicted, her lawyer said she would seek a jury trial rather than have Judge Hendon hear the case.
Mr. Montgomery said the teen was provoked into the attack.
A co-defendant, Gregory Douglas, 17, was ordered bound over to adult court Tuesday. The Westwood teen-ager was charged with aggravated assault. He is accused of putting Mr. Hall in a headlock after the older man had been splashed with bleach.
Prosecutors said Mr. Hall was upset with his daughter because he thought Mr. Douglas had spent the night in her room. The girl is accused of splashing Mr. Hall with bleach.
Mr. Hall was estranged from the girl's mother.
Mr. Hall's sister, Marvis Green, said the situation is difficult, but has not torn the family apart.
We are Christians and believe in the Lord Jesus. We ask God for guidance, Mrs. Green said.
The girl is being held in lieu of a $200,000 bond. Mr. Douglas is being held in lieu of a $100,000 bond.
Agreement reached in racial profiling
Neighbor charged in 3 Reading killings
Hugs for all from new city manager
Lemmie faces 9 council agendas
UC hoop star back in trouble
Gambling bill dies in committee
CAN set to unveil plan today
Children's to get $1.9M in study on improving care
Fire destroys home; officials seek owner
Girl's trial may be first under new law
Luken plays the veto card
Tristate A.M. Report
UC losing transplant director to Chicago
BRONSON: Spring break
HOWARD: Some Good News
SAMPLES: Destroyed art grew from determination
SMITH AMOS: Unrest, rebellion?
Female cop says she was mistreated
Quilter memorializes victims
Rally set to promote senior levy
School aide fired over drug charge
Three held after robbery at bank on Kenwood Road
Trial begins in robbery, murder case
Ohio tourism ad contract facing review
Cleanup campaigns begin this weekend
Contractor cited over blast that killed man
Developers aim to keep open space
House withholds action on budget
Lobbyist earns trust, respect
Northern Kentucky spring cleanups
Schools group drops chief