Monday, May 20, 2002
River is 'a very dangerous place'
By Tom O'Neill toneill@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer
For commercial transportation, few of the nation's highways beat the 981-mile-long Ohio River.
It's been a strategically located artery for centuries.
With the river inching closer today to flood stage, and choppy, wind-swept waters a week ago claiming two fishermen's lives, everything slows down.
A commercial towboat also sank last week, but no lives were lost.
The slower business moves, the higher the cost of doing business, which typically filters down to consumers.
But it beats the alternative of compromising safety, say those who work the river.
You do things with extreme caution, David Hammond, vice president of Edgewood, Ky.,-based Inland Marine Services, said Friday. It costs money to make these adjustments, but in the big picture, we're limiting our exposure. You won't take the risk.
Inland moves about 90,000 tons of product daily,most of it coal going to Cinergy. Coal now represents 55 percent, by tonnage, of all commercial transport that finds its way to you via the Ohio, according to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.
A barge alone could cost $300,000, plus the product, Mr. Hammond said. By the time you have an accident and sink one, you're looking at a $600,000 to $800,000 loss.
Commercial traffic on the Ohio has increased about 30 percent in the past decade, according to the Corps of Engineers. From 1989-98, the number of tows increased 25.3 percent at Meldahl Dam 45 miles east of Cincinnati in Clermont County, from 4,474 annually to 5,604.
That's a problem, because commercial crafts are far more difficult to maneuver than personal boats and crafts like jet skis.
It's a cautionary tale lost on some pleasure boaters, Coast Guard Lt. Commander Robert Bowen said Friday.
Today is the start of National Safe
Boating Week, when local, state and federal agencies, including the Coast Guard, will again emphasize three key boating lessons:
Always wear a life jacket.
Boat carefully, especially around commercial craft, and without impairment.
Get continued boating safety education, which is available in every state, often free of charge.
Though the increase in overall boating injuries and deaths is, in part, due to the rise in personal boat ownership in the past decade, the statistics are troubling, Lt. Bowen said.
According to Coast Guard figures from 2000, the most recent year available, Ohio had 198 water crashes, including 22 fatal accidents that killed 25 people.
The leading cause of crashes was collision between two vessels, with 59. Such collisions also were the leading cause of crashes in Kentucky, with 32 of the state's 98 crashes.
Ohio has the most boat registrations of any state in the United States, according to Coast Guard statistics.
For many years, Joe Betz, an 80-year-old Navy veteran from Mount Washington, had one of those.
The lifelong boater went down to Captain's Cove Marina on Columbia Tusculum Friday to look at the fast-moving Ohio River. He sized it up this way:
It's a fun place but you can't mess with it, you gotta respect the river, Mr. Betz said, avoiding the torential rain by sitting in his car with his wife, Norma. It's a dangerous place.
This is the heart of Lt. Bowen's message.
Towboats and barges are like a train on the tracks, they cannot stop, he said. They're restricted in the ability to maneuver. Pleasure crafts can turn quickly, these can't.
The rules of gross tonnage apply.
The perilous nature of the Ohio River is not always obvious from its banks.
Stand at the edge, close your eyes and listen to the majestic Ohio River lap its shore like a subtle metronome. It soothes the soul.
Open your eyes and watch seemingly calm water sweep west, calling boaters and recalling the painters and postcards that captured Cincinnati's famous front door.
It's all a lie.
It's a very dangerous place to be, said Dale Appel, Boone County Water Rescue captain. Fishing, pleasure crafts, any body. Even the commercial people are having problems. It's not a safe place to be.
It is unclear what led to the capsizing of the small boat in which longtime friends Danny Eaton, 27, of Foster, Ky., and Robert Wood, 24, of Falmouth, Ky., were fishing Monday near the Meldahl Dam.
A companion, Jeremy King, 25, of Colmansville, Ky., was rescued by a towboat.
Mr. Eaton and Mr. Wood are presumed drowned. The river currents were so strong in the days that followed, no divers or underwater equipment could be used in the recovery effort.
'After pastor' to help parish heal
March shows Catholic pride
River is 'a very dangerous place'
Flower Power blooms downtown
Record low of 30 shivers Tristate
BRONSON: Lettuce pickers in robes
Cemetery operator's trial begins
Ballpark's safety record pays off
College Hill wants police help in reclaiming neighborhood
Fake injury claim leads to arrest
Police investigate death of woman in parked car
Woman stabbed; son arrested
YWCA to honor women achievers
Arts Jam draws in families
'Cappies' program plans Tristate gala
Good News: Climb raises $30,000
Growth battle expands
Hamilton resists reopening fishing spot
Journalists go to fire boot camp
You Asked For It
Ohio to speed up DNA analysis in rape cases
Minister serves two churches
School violence examined
Three vie to be GOP candidate