Friday, May 31, 2002

Cause of death unclear


Doctor testifies in bleach inhalation

By Marie McCain, mmccain@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer

        Bleach may have contributed to the death of Archie Dale Hall, but it was not the sole cause, a forensic pathologist told a Hamilton County Juvenile Court jury Thursday.

        “He could have had some kind of pre-existing infection. But I don't believe he did,” said Dr. Gary Utz, who performed Mr. Hall's autopsy.

        He speculated Mr. Hall vomited and ingested the fluid, which then triggered the respiratory problems that led to his death. And, he added, if there was vomiting, it was caused by Mr. Hall's exposure to bleach.

        The 39-year-old Avondale man died in February three weeks after his teen-age daughter allegedly threw bleach on him during an argument over her 17-year-old boyfriend.

        The boyfriend, Gregory Douglas, is accused of placing Mr. Hall in a headlock after he'd been doused with bleach.

        According to court testimony, Mr. Douglas was trying to stop the older man from hitting him.

        The 15-year-old girl, who is not being named because she is a juvenile, is charged with involuntary manslaughter and felonious assault. She was 14 at the time of the Jan. 28 incident.

        The girl told authorities differing versions of what happened. Her father either punched or pushed her and she fell and spilled bleach on herself.

        She said the bleach burned her eyes and face and she tossed the bottle away before running out of her room. She said she didn't know if the bleach landed on her father.

        Prosecutors believe the girl intentionally threw bleach on her father. According to testimony, she threatened to throw something at Mr. Hall if he didn't leave her alone.

        Witnesses told authorities both the girl and Mr. Hall were drenched with bleach and that both complained of breathing problems.

        Earlier trial testimony indicated that bleach alone would probably not trigger the rapid onset of breathing problems that caused Mr. Hall's lungs to stiffen and fill with fluid.

        Defense attorneys hope to prove that Mr. Hall aspirated fluid during the struggle with the boyfriend.

        They say Mr. Hall was intoxicated at the time of the incident. He was seen consuming 52 ounces of beer before arguing with his daughter, according to trial testimony.

        The trial will resume Wednesday with the start of the defensecase.

       



$1.9 billion Ohio budget is approved
Highlights of Ohio's new budget
New tax goes after gains held in trusts
Team forming to woo Convergys
Ex-Cincinnatian feels awed by site
Blood drive fails to fix donor shortage
Blue Wisp Jazz Club finds new spot downtown
Carew Tower jumper dies in Fla.
- Cause of death unclear
Man who died in crash was facing robbery trial
Norwood plans bypass planners
Obituary: Roberta Maxey taught kindergarten 30 years
Rookies pass trial by fire; no one hurt in Evanston
Tristate A.M. Report
Two officers admit to sex with woman
BRONSON: Not pedophilia
HOWARD: Some Good News
SMITH AMOS: Opening windows
WELLS: Detainees
Developer issues apology for PR
Fire training hands-on
Grand jury won't hear youths' case
Judge: Teen's rights violated
Feds: Traficant doesn't deserve retrial
Higher hotel tax passes Senate
Another suit claims church coverup
Camp sessions may be cut
GOP leader wants deal on budget
Kentucky News Briefs
Reward sought for psychic help
School pay raise likely in Boone