Thursday, June 13, 2002

Judge shall not show poster


10 Commandments disallowed in court

The Associated Press

        CLEVELAND — A federal judge has ruled that a poster showing the Ten Commandments should not be displayed in a county courtroom.

        U.S. District Judge Kathleen O'Malley ruled Tuesday that Richland County Common Pleas Judge James DeWeese's purpose for posting the commandments is “generally laudable.”

        But she decided that his intention is “constitutionally deficient, because the debate he seeks to foster is inherently religious in character.”

        Judge DeWeese said Wednesday that he had not seen the ruling, but he insisted that he did nothing wrong.

        “I am confident of the legality and correctness of the challenged conduct and welcome the opportunity to take the case before a higher tribunal,” said Judge DeWeese, whose courtroom is in Mansfield, between Cleveland and Columbus.

        “We're disappointed with the decision,” said Gene Kapp, spokesman for American Center for Law and Justice, which represented Judge DeWeese. “But we're already working on our appeal. We are working on a number of Ten Commandment cases across the country.”

        Last year, the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio sued Judge DeWeese and the county commissioners. Bernard Davis, an ACLU member in Mansfield, objected to the poster and said the display made him feel as though the judge forced religion on him.

        But attorneys for Richland County said the Ten Commandments are more than a religious text, that they also provide a significant influence on the modern legal system.

        Mark Landes, a lawyer representing the Richland County commissioners, said Mr. O'Malley has been asked to drop the county commissioners as a defendant. The commissioners had no role in the display, he said.

        “The important point is it just goes to show how much our freedoms are under attack by the judicial system in America, especially the federal bench,” said Dan Hardwick, a Richland County commissioner.

        Judge DeWeese has said he has used the display to teach groups that tour his courtroom about the development of the legal system.

       



No outlet: You can't/get there from here
Priest's accuser details his story
City gun lawsuit can go forward
Schools fret over new busing rule
Blue Ash steps up sister city link
College moving ahead as it marks milestone
Flooding on agenda tonight in Anderson
New Fairfield preschool is a collaborative effort
Ohio justice seeks overseer role
Pete Rose to see new Reds park
Police, probation officers to check on convicts together
Tristate A.M. Report
PULFER: Tony Fischer
RADEL: Sleepless knight
Convicted nurse arrested in Mich.
Lebanon nears deal on buying school lot
Man ID'd by database gets prison in rape case
Man who cut off dogs' tails given jail
Bypass controversy
- Judge shall not show poster
Nuke-waste routes in Ohio protested
Ohio town firm on tracking solicitors
Shop owner charged with smuggling Honduran artifacts
University of Dayton's 'Brother Ray' retiring
Woman relieved after resolving Social Security bill for $102,000
Appeals court rules for drug-treatment clinic
Bears find home in park
Fire at school won't delay classes
Foal deaths linked to caterpillars
Kentucky News Briefs
Layoffs may signal another slowdown in coal mining
Man's death at mental-health clinic investigated
Regional reserves of blood trickling
Two dropped from school lawsuit