Thursday, July 25, 2002
Two accused of coupon scheme
By Janice Morse, jmorse@enquirer.com
The Cincinnati Enquirer
HAMILTON A Hamilton couple made thousands of dollars by obtaining stolen gift certificates for Pampers diapers and wipes, then selling them on the eBay Internet auction site, a police report says.
Butler County Prosecutor Robin Piper on Wednesday said the scope of the alleged scheme remained under investigation by his office's white-collar crime/consumer fraud unit, Hamilton city police and investigators in Hamilton County.
So far, he said, bank accounts have been seized, a home was searched and two people have been arrested: David Winsted, 34, and his wife, Toni Fowler, 36. They are charged with receiving stolen property and telecommunications fraud charges. The couple were arraigned Tuesday in Hamilton Municipal Court and are scheduled for a preliminary hearing Wednesday.
A woman who identified herself as Ms. Fowler hung up on a reporter Wednesday.
Court records say more than 2,000 of the coupons were found in a search of the couple's home Saturday. Police say the coupons had been stolen from Berman Printing Co., 1441 Western Ave., Cincinnati, which printed them.
Samantha German, a spokeswoman for Berman, declined to comment Wednesday.
The gift certificates were part of an Internet offer by Pampers' maker, Cincinnati-based Procter & Gamble Co., said Lisa Jester, a company spokeswoman.
Under the program, which began in October 2000 and ceased in early July, consumers could go online and purchase gift certificates for Pampers products.
No P&G employees have been identified as being involved in the alleged scheme, she said.
A search warrant filed Tuesday in Butler County Common Pleas Court says a Cincinnati detective had tracked $27,235 worth of stolen Pampers certificates to four different eBay accounts, including one in Hamilton. Further investigation led to Ms. Fowler and Mr. Winsted, the affidavit says.
Last week, a Hamilton city detective obtained a court order to view Ms. Fowler's eBay account. He found she was running two advertisements to sell 15 coupons for free tubs of Pampers wipes, court records say.
Kevin Pursglove, a spokesman for eBay, said $36 million worth of transactions occur through the site daily. Yet, he said, less than 0.01 percent of all eBay listings resulted in a confirmed case of fraud.
The number of fraud cases associated with stolen merchandise is even smaller, he said. We cooperate with law enforcement fully.
Steve Eder contributed to this report.
River park project to begin
Robbery brings out the cop in him
The color purple attracting attention
Retail complex closer to deal
More large projects north of Cincinnati
Arsonist hits Colerain Twp. again
Boycotters take call for sanctions to air
Flynt trial judge Wm. Morrissey dies
House OKs limit on abortion
Kings Island knows where Scooby-Doo is
Tristate A.M. Report
HOWARD: Some Good News
PULFER: Library closings
RADEL: Tall Stacks 2003
Hamilton seeking fire, police levies
Letter lists landfill concerns
Obituary: Jack Quinn, lawyer, S. Lebanon solicitor
Ross turns to voters for classrooms
Two accused of coupon scheme
Coast Guard asks help watching out for terrorism on Great Lakes
Dayton's new schools chief pledges progress
Killer's low IQ could save his life
Ohio native plants rediscovered
OSU said to have chosen woman president
Civil-rights pioneer Porterfield honored
Fire at self-storage facility destroys memories
Judge seals records in lawsuit against church
Kentucky News Briefs
Motorists can use computer to renew