Saturday, November 16, 2002
Clerks shouldn't hire kin
Kentucky is one of those places where ethics go to die. We still have public officials, for instance, who use their power to employ relatives.
This February, Kenton County Circuit Court Clerk Mary Ann Woltenberg hired her daughter, Lisa Cook, to fill a new position as her top assistant.
I checked state records. Ms. Cook makes $41,208 a year and is the highest-paid staffer in the office.
The average salary for a Kenton court clerk is $24,550, with an average seven years of service.
Job not advertised
Ms. Woltenberg, a Democrat first elected in 1992, says her daughter is a college graduate - unlike the other clerks - with strong computer skills that were badly needed in the office.
Previously, Ms. Cook had been a manager at Cincinnati Bell, where she earned $51,840. She got laid off three months before her mother hired her.
Ms. Woltenberg acknowledges that she neither advertised the position nor interviewed anyone else.
"I knew what her qualifications were, and you know in your family, you can trust them," she says.
Ms. Cook's duties include updating the clerk's Web site. She set up voicemail and e-mail for 50 employees. She compiled the phone numbers of all court officials and put them on spreadsheets. And when her mother is gone, she runs the office.
Both she and Ms. Woltenberg come and go more often than other employees, according to records from the county parking garage. They are more likely to be gone for an hour or two around lunchtime, for instance. On one day, May 9, mother and daughter both entered the garage at 8:20 a.m. and left an hour later, not to return that day, records show.
Ms. Woltenberg isn't sure what was happening then, but she has taken her daughter to the state capital several times for training, she says.
"I treat her the same as I treat everybody else....If she's left the building, it's because I've sent her to do something or it had something to do with work."
Ohio law tougher
Some might say Kenton County is lucky to have Lisa Cook. Regardless, parents shouldn't be hiring and supervising their children on the public dime. It's too easy for favoritism and waste to creep in. Too easy for other workers to perceive unfairness.
Ohio law prohibits such nepotism. Hamilton County Court Clerk James Cissell has an even stricter rule: He refuses to hire not only his own relatives but also those of any current employee.
"The relative may be highly qualified, but to do away with not only impropriety but the appearance of it, I think the rule is important," Mr. Cissell says.
Not in Kentucky.
Ms. Woltenberg's hiring of her daughter was approved by the state's Administrative Office of the Courts, which also authorized the high salary.
AOC works for the chief justice of the Kentucky Supreme Court. Neither the justice nor the legislature has established an ethics code for court clerks.
If the clerks won't police themselves, somebody else should.
kgutierrez@enquirer.com or 859-578-5584.
TOP HEADLINES:
Freshman congressman learns the ropes
DeWine will run in 2006
Seven children left behind after fatal crash
Planners end opposition to retail center
ENQUIRER COLUMNS:
Gutierrez: Clerks shouldn't hire kin
McNUTT: Town keeps Civil War roots alive
CINCINNATI-HAMILTON COUNTY
Davis reviews NAACP role
Russian Jews learning to work with police
Robbery Task Force returns for holidays
Anderson Ferry work time extended
OBITUARIES
W. Scott Brown was war hero
Marian Torbeck, `model of kindness'
IN THE TRISTATE
Tristate A.M. Report
Congrats
BUTLER COUNTY
Fairfield school focuses on arts
WARREN COUNTY
Joint effort cracks spree of robberies
Come to Enquirer's town hall meeting at The Golden Lamb
CLERMONT COUNTY
Street getting old-fashioned facelift
OHIO
Charter school growth stumbles
Ohio college interns dismayed: No scholarships
Clinic receives trove of frozen eyeballs
Fire, explosions prompt evacuations
Charters' nonprofit status debated
KENTUCKY
Drug an issue in Craven trial
Officials still want streetcars
Lucas opposed new House Dem leader
School inaugurates first president
Ky. budget forecast: $350M short
Democrat leaves party post
Nursing home owner in bankruptcy court
Senate confirms UK professor as judge
Kentucky Briefs
Anti-gay preacher opposed
INDIANA
Couple may lose custody of baby
Ind. considers another route for highway
Doctor found to have been imprisoned for kidnapping
Anderson mayor, wife deny abuse
Some merchants worry end of 24-hour patrols causing crime
City demolishes 2 buildings it didn't own