Wednesday, November 20, 2002

Prison rape


Cruel and unusual torture

map

One of the most lawless places in America is on the wrong side of a prison door. Just ask an ex-con.

"The biggest and baddest guy in prison had the showers every afternoon from 1 to 2. When you'd see a towel hanging over the top, you knew not to go into the showers,'' said Cliff Stubbers, a former Ohio inmate. "You knew Steve was in there.''

Steve was not alone.

Men get raped in prison more often than women get raped outside prisons, according to Stop Prison Rape, a non-profit group (www.spr.org) . The group claims 240,000 male inmates are raped each year compared to 140,000 women on the outside.

An open secret

"It's part of prison life,'' said Mr. Stubbers, a former Indian Hill resident who served eight years for a sex crime he insists he did not commit. "It's the young ones, especially. Every time I see a young boy go to prison, I shake my head.''

Prosecutors, judges and cops know about the "special'' punishment child molesters get in prison. Prison officials know about it, too, but most don't keep records. Ohio Prisons spokeswoman Andrea Dean said records show 11 sexual assaults in 2000, three last year and five this year. But she says underreporting is "very probable, because inmates have a fear of retaliation.''

Studies cited by SPR estimate that 20 percent of men and 27 percent of women in prison are raped. Juveniles are five times more likely to be assaulted. Prisoners are 10 times more likely to spread AIDS, making rape a tacked-on death sentence for some victims. Some "punks'' become slaves for years to avoid beatings or death. Then they are set free like walking grenades, ready to explode with shrapnel rage.

And we joke about it. Young men wear the low-riding prison jeans and think they are "cool.'' TV ads and movies wink and elbow us in the ribs about what happens in prison.

Charles Colson, founder of Prison Ministries Fellowship, has visited 600 prisons in 25 years since he served time for Watergate crimes. He says he has seen "utter devastation created by rape in prison.''

`No big deal'

He says, "We may be tempted, in the privacy of our hearts, to whisper, `They deserve it.' But no matter what crime somebody had committed, no part of his sentence should include being sexually assaulted, exposed to sexually transmitted diseases, such as AIDS or hepatitis C, or degraded.''

By any definition, prison rape equals cruel and unusual punishment.

A bill in the U.S. House and the Senate would set up a national commission to collect statistics and find ways to prosecute and prevent prison rape.

During testimony in Congress, Linda Bruntmyer told about her son Rodney Hulkin - a little guy, sent to prison at age 16 for vandalism. He was repeatedly raped and beaten. Before he hanged himself, his mother asked the warden for help. She says she was told, "This happens to everybody, learn to deal with it. It's no big deal.''

It is a big deal. It shouldn't happen to anyone. But it is time to deal with it.

E-mail pbronson@enquirer.com or call 768-8301.




TOP STORIES
Research millions pay off
Pennsylvania fugitive hid in plain sight
Suspect in attack a repeat offender

IN THE TRISTATE
Council members defend ouster
Letter from Councilman Pat DeWine
Letter from Department of Justice
City set to aid minority firms
Band is marching on air
Developers ask Norwood's help
Community rallies for ill boy, family
Park may drop planned art
Tristate A.M. Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
SMITH-AMOS: All smiles
BRONSON: Prison rape
GUTIERREZ: God and machine
KORTE: City Hall
HOWARD: Some Good News

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Miami students arrested on drug charges
Gospel singer gets 6 months in jail for molesting 3 teens
5-trustee board short in tally
Election win heats up Warren official's fight with developers
Butler's boom draws public forum
New pool puts swim team in fast lane

OHIO
Religious markers at schools must go
Nursing home reforms questioned
Increased vehicle pollution to be allowed under request

KENTUCKY
N. Kentucky falls far off pace during record home-sale year
Lambert seeking to expand family courts
Kentucky leads in lung cancer
Judge: Craven trial in trouble
New jobs in N.Ky. down nearly 90% in one year
Florence team's name patriotic