Wednesday, December 18, 2002
Miami escapes from Heisman 'jinx'
By CRAIG HANDEL
The (Fort Myers, Fla.) News-Press
NEW YORK CITY - Now that they didn't win the Heisman Trophy, University of Miami tailback Willis McGahee and quarterback Ken Dorsey can get back to what they've really been working for all season - winning a second straight national championship.
The incentive is there now, big time. After nearly being shut out for all of the postseason awards, the Hurricanes can use that perceived snub to gain an edge for the Jan. 3 Fiesta Bowl matchup against Ohio State.
While Southern California's Carson Palmer won the award, McGahee finished fourth and Dorsey fifth. Last year, Dorsey came in third.
"The pressure is off," McGahee said.
That may be more true than he'll ever know. Based on the past quarter century of Heisman history, winning the top individual award often hasn't translated into winning the top team honor.
Since 1974, Heisman Trophy winners' teams are 11-16 in bowl games. In fact, players like Nebraska's Eric Crouch (2001), Florida State's Chris Weinke (2000), Miami's Gino Torretta (1992) and Vinny Testaverde (1986), Nebraska's Mike Rozier (1983) and Ohio State's Archie Griffin (1974, 1975) saw their teams lose in bowl games that cost them possible national championships.
"It's that right there," Dorsey said. "I think almost in a way it's good for Willis and myself not to have the added pressure (while) going to a bowl game, a national championship game. I think that will help us. Even though I finished dead last in the Heisman voting, I'm still going to the Fiesta Bowl last I checked."
While it didn't surprise people that Palmer won, the margin of his victory did. His 242 first-place votes and 1,328 total votes were more than the combined votes of McGahee (101; 660) and Dorsey (122; 643).
"I was very surprised," McGahee said. "I thought it would be a close race.
"But there's no disappointment. I didn't expect to win."
While expressing happiness for Palmer and gratitude to the Heisman Trophy officials, Dorsey took a swipe or two at the national media. He added the burden of living up to high acclaim wore on him this season. While Dorsey felt lashing out wouldn't be a good example to youths who see him as a role model, Palmer admitted not being on television often was a good thing. Unlike Dorsey, he didn't have to deal with the constant scrutiny or game-by-game analysis.
"I think the expectations coming into the season were definitely high," Dorsey said. "I would imagine in some people's minds I didn't fulfill those expectations. I didn't throw for 5,000 yards, or have a 75 percent completion percentage."
Among Miami players, only center Brett Romberg came away with hardware, the Rimington Award. After joking how he always has to clean and shine Dorsey's various honors, Romberg now has one of his own. But the fact that he may be the only player receiving a trophy is going to light a fire under a team which uses any slight to rally around.
Wednesday, it's back to the practice field. It's where Dorsey is most comfortable. It's where he can start toward defending that national championship. And with another great performance, it's where he can earn a third straight bowl MVP trophy.
"That means the most, the national championship, the biggest venue in college football," Dorsey said. "We want to go out, and to be perfectly honest, we feel there's almost a level of respect we have to earn."
Heisman jinx Since Archie Griffin won the first of his two awards in 1974, Heisman Trophy winners are 11-16 when leading their team in bowl games:
Year .. Winner .......... Bowl result
2002: Carson Palmer, USC ???
2001: Eric Crouch, Nebraska lost to Miami 37-14 in Rose Bowl
2000: Chris Weinke, Florida State lost to Oklahoma 13-2 in Orange Bowl
1999: Ron Dayne, Wisconsin beat Stanford 17-9 in Rose Bowl
1998: Ricky Williams, Texas beat Mississippi State 38-11 in Cotton Bowl
1997: Charles Woodson, Michigan beat Washington State 21-16 in Rose Bowl
1996: Danny Wuerffel, Florida beat Florida State 52-20 in Sugar Bowl
1995: Eddie George, Ohio State lost to Tennessee 20-14 in Hall of Fame Bowl
1994: Rashaan Salaam, Colorado beat Notre Dame 41-24 in Fiesta Bowl
1993: Charlie Ward, Florida State beat Nebraska 18-17 in Orange Bowl
1992: Gino Torretta, Miami lost to Alabama 34-13 in Sugar Bowl
1991: Desmond Howard, Michigan lost to Washington 34-14 in Rose Bowl
1990: Ty Detmer, BYU lost to Texas A&M 65-14 in Holiday Bowl
1989: Andre Ware, Houston didn't play in postseason
1988: Barry Sanders, Oklahoma State beat Wyoming 62-14 in Holiday Bowl
1987: Tim Brown, Notre Dame lost to Texas A&M 35-10 in Cotton Bowl
1986: Vinny Testaverde, Miami lost to Penn State 14-10 in Fiesta Bowl
1985: Bo Jackson, Auburn lost to Texas A&M 36-16 in Cotton Bowl
1984: Doug Flutie, Boston College beat Houston 45-28 in Cotton Bowl
1983: Mike Rozier, Nebraska lost to Miami 31-30 in Orange Bowl
1982: Herschel Walker, Georgia lost to Penn State 27-23 in Sugar Bowl
1981: Marcus Allen, USC lost to Penn State 26-10 in Fiesta Bowl
1980: George Rogers, South Carolina lost to Pittsburgh 37-9 in Gator Bowl
1979: Charles White, USC beat Ohio State 17-16 in Rose Bowl
1978: Billy Sims, Oklahoma beat Nebraska 31-24 in Orange Bowl
1977: Earl Campbell, Texas lost to Notre Dame 38-10 in Cotton Bowl
1976: Tony Dorsett, Pittsburgh beat Georgia 27-3 in Sugar Bowl
1975: Archie Griffin, Ohio State lost to UCLA 23-10 in Rose Bowl
1974: Archie Griffin, Ohio State lost to USC 18-17 in Rose Bowl
UC HOOPS
Waddling not in plan for Ducks
Bearcats want to see less of hefty Grove
Little hearing pushed to June
COLLEGE BASKETBALL
Pitino honors brother-in-law with tourney
UC women drop from poll
AP Top 25 poll
USA TODAY/ESPN Top 25 poll
UC FOOTBALL
Gino is the man
Mean Green wants to prove relevance
COLLEGE FOOTBALL
Clarett liked 'Canes, but not enough to fly
Sun Devil Stadium gets ready for Fiesta
Three Buckeyes head AP All-American squad
Miami escapes from Heisman 'jinx'
Miami coordinator pleads innocent to battery charge
BENGALS / NFL
Opinion on Bengals' lease remains secret
LeBeau refuses to rip Bengals
Brady, Patriots grounded by Titans defense
Harrington done for season
Watch out for losing teams
REDS / WINTER MEETINGS
Reds think spring
Reds pick Prokopec, two others in Rule 5 Draft
Gil Hodges deserves a spot in Hall of Fame
Reliever Stanton headed across town to Mets
PREP SPORTS
Perry's 21 points fuel Fayetteville
LeBron James scores 31 points in Pittsburgh game
High school swimming results
High school basketball leaders
Prep hoops schedule
PLAN YOUR DAY
Sports on TV