Saturday, September 27, 2003

2 families get $3.1M for claims


Kin of shooting victims have most of cop-settlement pool

By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer

The family of Timothy D. Thomas will get $1.5 million for the 2001 police shooting death that led to four days of riots in Over-the-Rhine, according to a settlement proposal filed in Hamilton County Probate Court Thursday.

Michael D. Carpenter's estate will get $1.6 million for its wrongful death claim arising out of a 1999 police shooting in Northside.

Both cases were part of a $4.5 million "global settlement" approved by Cincinnati City Council in May. The monetary damages helped settle a racial profiling lawsuit that also resulted in reforms in how Cincinnati police officers use force against suspects.

The individual judgment amounts were secret until Thursday, when the estates of both men filed applications in Hamilton County Probate Court to approve the distribution of the individual settlements.

Both families will pay $500,000 out of their judgments for attorneys' fees, according to the probate filings.

After legal fees in the Thomas case, his mother, Angela Leisure, would receive $700,000 and Thomas' 2-year-old son, Tywon, would get $300,000.

Thomas, 19, was wanted on 14 misdemeanor warrants and was running from police April 7, 2001, when Officer Stephen Roach shot him in an alley off Republic Street in Over-the-Rhine.

In the Carpenter case, parents Elsie A. and Fred L. Carpenter would get $350,000 and $250,000, respectively. A 12-year-old daughter, Tyeisha M. Carpenter, would receive $250,000. Five adult brothers and sisters would get $50,000 each.

Carpenter, 31, was pulled over in a traffic stop in Northside March 19, 1999. Though the facts are still in dispute, two officers said they shot him after his car lurched backward at the officers.

Neither family could be reached for comment. Their lawyers said they were satisfied with the settlements based on the facts of the cases and the odds of winning at trial.

"In more than half the cases that go to trial, the plaintiffs lose. Jurors tend to accept the versions of events given by police, especially when you have a conservative jurisdiction like we have here," said attorney Kenneth L. Lawson.

The settlements mean the remaining 14 plaintiffs in the federal lawsuit over racial profiling will split the remaining $1.4 million, or an average of $100,000. Their claims mostly arose out of allegations of profiling in traffic stops.

City Council has approved issuing bonds to borrow the money to pay the $4.5 million settlement.

E-mail gkorte@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Overnight storm causes heavy damage in Warren Co.
Rape victim jailed; accused freed
Injured athlete voted homecoming king
Strikers ready for long haul
2 families get $3.1M for claims

IN THE TRISTATE
Brand new on the menu: freshly painted Big Mac
Catholic schools scramble to reverse slide
'Survivor' sags in Cincinnati
Let's all talk about education
Catholic teachers mostly disagree with Ky. firing
School to open new building
Tests show bacteria in Loveland school water
27 home sick after ruling on overtime
School reunion unites West Side
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Letting the homeless be squatters is inhumane
Howard: Good Things Happening
Faith matters: Families fight death penalty
McNutt: Marker dedication gives Black Brigade limelight

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Crunch time near for Apple Festival
Cities to debate mall aid
Fernald projects shut down
Warren college director picks awaited

OBITUARIES
Richard Langenbeck, 80, was retired lawyer
Librarian Althea Lazenby found adventure in India
Kentucky obituaries

OHIO
ACLU sues over executions
Ohio's grid recorded at least 64 glitches
Cemetery offers free burial plot
State fair director resigns under fire
4 teens critical from bad weed
Bush leads all comers in Ohio
Pipeline project fined for violations
Pfeifer wins GOP nod - and nays
Workers hustle, boy gets heart
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Fletcher health-care plan pushes Rx reform
Kentucky News Briefs
Governor debate at NKU
Do you know this donkey? He's lost and needs a home
Bishop backs diocese report
New school lunch program: Staff visits parents' homes
Lexington smoking ban halted
Kentucky To Go