Friday, October 3, 2003

Ex-mayors: City on wrong path


Reform planners hear blunt talk

By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Two former Cincinnati mayors told an election reform panel Thursday that cutting council salaries and improving regional cooperation would be more effective in fixing city government than drawing district lines on a map.

"A lot of the problems we've been reading about involve council members crossing the borders of what their jobs are supposed to be about," said Arn Bortz, a Charterite mayor from 1983 to 1984. "City Council members spend too much time at City Hall, interfering with the administration."

Eugene P. Ruehlmann, the Republican mayor from 1967 to 1971, said the Electoral Reform Commission set up by City Council is "focusing on the wrong thing.

"I am compelled to say that the changes we need in Cincinnati are not going to be brought about by electoral reform," he said. He said the city's economic problems are regional issues, and that Cincinnati represents a smaller part of the region now than it did when he was mayor and presided over an aborted attempt to move toward a metropolitan government.

"I am so sick and tired of the county and the city at loggerheads," Ruehlmann told the commission. "I would prefer to see all the time and energy you're spending on electoral reform devoted to solving that problem."

The 13-member panel is studying what would be the most radical changes to city government since the 1925 charter. Options include a return to ward-by-ward elections and the elimination of the city manager.

At its second meeting Thursday, the commission brought in political scientists and elder statesmen of the city to better understand how the current political system developed and what the alternatives are.

Among them, there was greater support for the at-large system of elections or - at the extreme - a hybrid system that would include both citywide and district representation.

Former Councilman John J. Gilligan - who now serves on the Cincinnati Board of Education - said a district system wouldn't empower neighborhoods as much as supporters suggest.

"That's not power. Now you've got one person on City Council. The game remains to be played," he said. A district system would encourage "horse-trading" among ward councilmen, he said.

The commission will hold its first public hearing at 6 p.m. Oct. 16 at Jordan Crossing in Bond Hill.

E-mail gkorte@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Police shut down crime ring
For sale, dream house, $11.9M
Stadium deal got worse
Woman: Priest molested me, too
21 men join lawsuit against accused priest
Newport's submarine gets OK in defense bill
Lewis and Clark come alive at Kentucky's Big Bone Lick

IN THE TRISTATE
Fire safety fairs open this week
Police union can't withdraw
Ex-mayors: City on wrong path
Grant aims to curb smoking
On campus
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Crowley: Race is on for N.Ky outdoor shopping complex
Downs: Small, quaint, relaxing place lures coffee aficionados
Howard: Good Things Happening

BUTLER, WARREN, CLERMONT
Antique car show is area classic
Fatal wreck results in jail
Wavy flag leads to lawsuit

OBITUARIES
Charles Hawley ran ink manufacturer
Ellen Thompson, 96, had deep Ohio roots
Kentucky Obituaries

OHIO
Fingerhut redefines 'underdog'
Cause of fatal silo blast could take days to find
Ohio Moments

KENTUCKY
Copter takes man to hospital after fall
Accused EMT trainee fired after visiting teen
The Enquirer wants to know what you think
Watergate reporter, TV host air views
Conner guilty of mail fraud
Pharmacy board opposes splitting pills to save dollars for Medicaid
Kentucky to do