Tuesday, October 7, 2003

Judge withholds racial data


Profiling study kept secret in suit against city

By Gregory Korte
The Cincinnati Enquirer

University of Cincinnati researchers have completed their study of whether Cincinnati police target African-American motorists - but have been ordered by a federal judge not to disclose their findings.

A federal magistrate issued a gag order on the racial-profiling report Monday.

Plaintiffs in a class-action lawsuit against the city had argued against disclosure, saying the parties need additional time to analyze the report.

Under the order by U.S. Magistrate Judge Michael R. Merz, the soonest the analysis could be released is 45 days.

The issue of racial profiling has been a central question in the city's police reform efforts. In May 2001 - a month after a police shooting in Over-the-Rhine led to riots - City Council required officers to record the race, gender and age of every person they came into contact with.

UC professor John Eck has been analyzing those 50,000 contact cards for two years in an effort to find out whether police improperly target African-Americans.

Since then, the data collection has been wrapped into the racial-profiling lawsuit settlement, also called the collaborative agreement.

The court's gag order came after City Council's Law and Public Safety Committee moved to make the information public. Chairman Pat DeWine said that because taxpayers paid for police to collect the data, they deserve to know what it says.

"The collaborative should not be used to insulate important information from the public," DeWine said. "The police have been collecting this data for too long without there being a public discussion about the value of it."

But Kenneth L. Lawson, a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union of Ohio, said the findings should be kept under wraps until after the Nov. 4 City Council election.

"We don't want it to be used to further somebody's political agenda," he said.

Instead, lawyers for all sides - including the Cincinnati Police Department and the Fraternal Order of Police Queen City Lodge No. 69 - should take time to decide what changes, if any, should be made in response to Eck's analysis.

"The findings are very complex. Let's say there's evidence that blacks are getting stopped more often than whites. Does that mean there's racial profiling?" Lawson said.

---

E-mail gkorte@enquirer.com




ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Pulfer: Permanent 'Purple People P&G Bridge' pending
Korte: Inside City Hall

TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Sewer fixes could triple bills
Taft hails Genome Institute alliance
Cancer drug offers hope
Brides say dress shop jilted them
Judge withholds racial data
Officials getting free storage

TRISTATE HEADLINES
Munoz featured at Butler Chamber
Warren candidate accused
Defense: Slaying wasn't planned
Woman accused of taking $565,000
4 areas could split $44,314
Bicyclist wears heart on sleeve
Domestic call leads to meth lab
Student aims to bolster safety
Students to spend night in boxes
Regional Report
National Guard saves cemetery from disrepair

KENTUCKY HEADLINES
Big bash is worth beans
Campers to take case to the feds
Kids on air in living color
Man jailed after gunfire
Lexington smoking ban still on hold
Kentucky to do

GREAT NEIGHBORHOODS
Our guide to Montgomery and Sycamore Township

OBITUARIES
Genevieve E. Hilmer, arts philanthropist
Franklin Pierce Finnicum, 87