Tuesday, October 14, 2003

Court asked to consider drunken driving evidence



The Associated Press

COLUMBUS - Prosecutors say evidence from tests of drunken drivers should be used in trials even if police didn't follow all the rules while giving the tests.

Defense attorneys say the Ohio Supreme Court has already said such evidence can't be admitted in court.

Both sides have asked the justices to resolve conflicting rulings in other courts. A ruling is expected by year's end.

"We don't know what it means if it's done improperly, so what's a jury going to do with these tests?" said James Tesno, a Celina attorney who successfully argued to have test results thrown out in his client's drunken driving case.

At issue is an earlier Supreme Court ruling on police use of evidence in sobriety tests when deciding whether to arrest suspected drunken drivers.

In August 2000, the Supreme Court ruled that police who don't properly conduct sobriety tests can't use them as evidence. The court's 4-3 decision - known as State v. Homan - upheld a lower court ruling that overturned an Erie County woman's 1996 conviction on drunken driving.




TOP LOCAL STORIES
Proposal: Combine levy votes
Three settle with diocese
Fairfax can't raise money to buy flood-prone homes
'Miracle child' returns to school
Fire union awaits action on fired chaplain

LOCAL COLUMNISTS
Pulfer: Prayers, power tools lay Father Jim's foundation
Howard: Good Things Happening
Korte: Hypocrisy abounds when council votes

CINCINNATI-HAMILTON COUNTY
Mideast solutions explored
CPS approves designs for Withrow, Millvale
Madeira school remembers principal
United Way recruits women
Revised condo design gets OK
Forum puts boycott front and center

AROUND THE REGION
School, hospital ready to team up
Monroe sloppy with money
Regional Report
In The Schools

OBITUARIES
UC's Anthony Grasha a top psychologist
Orville Morgan, church founder

OHIO
Bioterror bill alters access
Court asked to consider drunken driving evidence
Ohio Moments: Tireless researcher made history with book

KENTUCKY
Plucky kids get ready for first strings concert
Officials: Dog thieves likely not in ring
Lewis and Clark papers displayed
Boys & Girls clubs get $100K
Around the Commonwealth
Patton orders fiscal review