Thursday, November 20, 2003

Settlement deal likely in church abuse case


Plea would end criminal inquiry into archdiocese

By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

The Archdiocese of Cincinnati is expected to enter a plea to a criminal charge today as part of a deal that would end an investigation into clergy sexual abuse.

The deal is the product of several days of settlement talks between church lawyers and Hamilton County prosecutors, who have spent nearly two years investigating the archdiocese's handling of abuse cases.

The deal is believed to be the first in the country to require a diocese or a church official to plead to criminal charges related to the abuse crisis.

Attorneys on both sides met Wednesday with Common Pleas Judge Richard Niehaus to discuss the status of their negotiations and to schedule a court hearing for this afternoon.

"They didn't tell me what the deal was," Judge Niehaus said. "It's between them."

The meeting with the judge is the first indication the case was moving toward a plea deal, as opposed to an out-of-court settlement. Prosecutors and church lawyers declined comment on the case and potential charges involved, but several plea scenarios are possible.

One is a deal in which the archdiocese - rather than an individual church official - would plead guilty or no contest to criminal charges.

A guilty plea would require the church to acknowledge wrongdoing, while a no-contest plea would not require such an admission.

No matter how the plea deal plays out this afternoon, it will likely resolve all pending issues related to prosecutor Mike Allen's criminal investigation of the archdiocese.

The deal will not, however, affect pending lawsuits filed during the past year by people who claim they were victims of abusive priests.

Those suits, which involve more than 50 alleged victims and at least four priests, would have to be settled or resolved in court on a case-by-case basis. Three additional lawsuits against some of those priests were filed Wednesday.

The rapid progress toward resolution in the criminal case began early this week as prosecutors prepared to convene a grand jury to investigate how the archdiocese responded - or failed to respond - to abuse allegations.

Prosecutors agreed to postpone grand jury proceedings pending the outcome of settlement talks. Church officials, meanwhile, agreed to give prosecutors some documents related to abuse claims.

Church officials had previously refused to turn over those documents, arguing they were confidential communication with their lawyers.

The movement toward a more comprehensive deal picked up steam Wednesday when Allen, Assistant Prosecutor Mark Piepmeier and archdiocese attorney Mark VanderLaan met behind closed doors with Niehaus.

The lawyers would not comment as they left the courtroom, but the judge confirmed a deal was in the works.

Although no criminal charges have been filed, the case was assigned to Niehaus as part of a process known as a "pre-roll." This process allows a case to be randomly assigned to a judge before an indictment or criminal charge is filed.

The process also clears the way for defendants to plead guilty or no contest to a crime, even though they have not yet been formally charged.

The criminal investigation in Hamilton County began last year after Archbishop Daniel Pilarczyk acknowledged that the archdiocese continued to employ five priests despite past allegations of abuse.

All five have since been suspended. But until recently, prosecutors and church officials had clashed often over the church's handling of abuse claims and its refusal to hand over some documents.

A grand jury earlier this year indicted two priests on abuse charges, but the new grand jury was expected to focus more on church officials who supervised abusive priests than on the priests themselves.

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
State spending reforms sought
Web site will list those who have cheated state
Settlement deal likely in church abuse case
Here's how to keep your number
Cell phone blitz hits Monday
Center for arts will open soon

IN THE TRISTATE
Anderson Twp. considers limiting on-street parking
Blackout blamed on FirstEnergy errors
Butler leaders fire latest volley in E-check battle
'42nd Street' will have you tapping your toes
Three violinists to carry on CCM teaching
Clermont closer to calling two winners from Nov. 4 election
Scores, truants targets at CPS
Hamilton gets into holiday spirit
New police hire brings Loveland special skills
Contact lens wearers would get right to Rx
Norwood honors pharmacist
Road upgrade awaits church sale vote
Loveland drops tax plan for levy
Hospital site to be firmed up in Jan.
Mt. Washington streetscape nearly ready to be dedicated
Schwarzkopf: It starts with character
City joins in multicultural Thanksgiving celebration
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Gay marriage is a topic wired with explosives
Howard: Good Things Happening

OBITUARIES
Duncan R. Nutting, 85, was Marine to the core
Kentucky obituaries

OHIO
State education officials suspend assessment tests
Ohio moments

KENTUCKY
Three Ky. arts groups win grants
County wants to buy battlefield
Kentucky News Briefs
Campbell schools eye calendar
Nine women seeking pardons from Patton
Husband guilty in wife's murder
Ex-chairwoman on ethics panel
Judge hears arguments over motion to dismiss schools suit
Another Democrat gunning for Bunning
Eateries, others adopt today's theme: No smoking
Kentucky things to do