Thursday, November 20, 2003

Gay marriage is a topic wired with explosives



Peter Bronson

Whenever I see a headline about "gay marriage,'' I get this sinking feeling. It's always the same story.

There's a photo of a loving, caring, monogamous lesbian couple, raising adopted orphans. "We only want the rights given to everyone else,'' they plead.

On the other side, buried deep in the story, is an opponent of gay marriage, with a quote like an anthropology lecture: "Marriage between one man and one woman has formed the foundation of civilization for thousands of years.''

It's emotion vs. logic.

And logic has about as much chance of surviving this debate as a slice of crisp bacon at a meeting of Atkins Dieters Anonymous. In our Oprah-fied culture, blubbery emotion must be fed. So the definition of marriage that has outlasted the Great Pyramids and crosses more cultural, geographic, religious and ethnic boundaries than the Great Wall of China is crumbling under the slow drip of "I want.''

"It puts us at a challenge,'' says Ohio Rep. Bill Seitz, R-Green Township, sponsor of a Defense of Marriage Act. His bill, scheduled for hearings this month, reinforces the existing Ohio definition of marriage as one man and one woman. "If we respond equally emotional, self-righteous and moralizing, we lose. We have to be like Sgt. Joe Friday - just the facts.''

Seitz says the strongest argument is that 38 states and the federal government have already passed such laws. If Ohio doesn't do the same, it could be forced to recognize homosexual unions approved in Vermont and Canada, and now Massachusetts.

His bill wouldn't block private employers from providing benefits to gays. But it would protect Ohio from being forced by the courts to recognize gay marriages performed in other states.

Seitz says the state has a duty to protect heterosexual marriage, "without which the species ceases to exist.''

If homosexual marriage is allowed, "The question then becomes, what other practices are we going to legitimize?'' Seitz says.

Public officials have been burned at the media stake for daring to point out the obvious legal truth: Once the barrier that defines marriage is kicked down, nothing is left to stop polygamy and deviant "lifestyles'' between consenting adults.

Polls show most Americans oppose gay marriage. Support comes mainly from liberal courts, Hollyweird and the media. But debate is stifled by a minefield of craters and barbed wire.

"They will demonize us,'' said Seitz. He's been through it before, when his bill passed the House two years ago and was blocked in the Senate. "It will be the usual litany of names: homophobic, nasty, moralistic, narrow-minded, self-righteous and bigoted. I'm going to try to take as much emotion out of it as possible.''

That's fine in the political arena. But in the WWF ring of public opinion, book-smart logic loses the smackdown.

Maybe opponents should instead point out the likely victims of free-for-all marriage: children. Marriage has been battered by rising divorce, co-habitation, politically correct "domestic partner'' benefits, welfare policy and a culture that winks at infidelity, even in the White House.

The ones who suffer are children in fractured families, stuck in poverty, failing in school, slipping into crime and teen pregnancy.

You can say marriage is defined by God or biology. Defying either one is just asking for trouble.

E-mail pbronson@enquirer.com or call 768-8301.




TOP STORIES
State spending reforms sought
Web site will list those who have cheated state
Settlement deal likely in church abuse case
Here's how to keep your number
Cell phone blitz hits Monday
Center for arts will open soon

IN THE TRISTATE
Anderson Twp. considers limiting on-street parking
Blackout blamed on FirstEnergy errors
Butler leaders fire latest volley in E-check battle
'42nd Street' will have you tapping your toes
Three violinists to carry on CCM teaching
Clermont closer to calling two winners from Nov. 4 election
Scores, truants targets at CPS
Hamilton gets into holiday spirit
New police hire brings Loveland special skills
Contact lens wearers would get right to Rx
Norwood honors pharmacist
Road upgrade awaits church sale vote
Loveland drops tax plan for levy
Hospital site to be firmed up in Jan.
Mt. Washington streetscape nearly ready to be dedicated
Schwarzkopf: It starts with character
City joins in multicultural Thanksgiving celebration
Regional Report

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Gay marriage is a topic wired with explosives
Howard: Good Things Happening

OBITUARIES
Duncan R. Nutting, 85, was Marine to the core
Kentucky obituaries

OHIO
State education officials suspend assessment tests
Ohio moments

KENTUCKY
Three Ky. arts groups win grants
County wants to buy battlefield
Kentucky News Briefs
Campbell schools eye calendar
Nine women seeking pardons from Patton
Husband guilty in wife's murder
Ex-chairwoman on ethics panel
Judge hears arguments over motion to dismiss schools suit
Another Democrat gunning for Bunning
Eateries, others adopt today's theme: No smoking
Kentucky things to do