By Cindy Kranz
The Cincinnati Enquirer
In 2002, Thomas Higgins was principal of Aiken High School and set to become principal of Princeton High School. Princeton Superintendent Don Darby told Higgins he would submit his name to the school board and approval was just a formality.
But before the May 13 board meeting, when Darby planned to recommend Higgins, the Princeton superintendent was presented with a "fact sheet" that painted Higgins as a racist.
Four of the five allegations of racial discord at Aiken were later proven false. Even so, Princeton bid goodbye to Higgins.
Later that year, Higgins got a job as principal of Kings High School. But he sued the man he said is responsible for creating the fact sheet for defamation of character.
Timothy Moore, assistant principal under Higgins at Aiken, is now assistant principal at Western Hills High School. He denied the allegations, and his attorney, Carl Lewis, said there's no evidence to prove Moore wrote the fact sheet.
On Monday, however, a Hamilton County Common Pleas jury, in a 6-2 vote, agreed with Higgins, awarding him $275,000 in compensatory damages, $100,000 in punitive damages and attorneys' fees.
"It's about as an egregious of a character assassination as you'll ever see," said Randy Freking, Higgins' attorney.
In a three-day trial, the story unfolded like this:
Higgins was told his name, alone, would be submitted to the board.
On May 7, 2002, Higgins signed a consultant's contract with Princeton, which would allow him to get acclimated.
Six days later, Darby received a call from the Rev. DeQuincy Hentz, Moore's pastor at Mount Zion Baptist Church in Woodlawn, a Princeton community.
Hentz started telling Darby his concerns about Higgins. When Darby arrived at the board meeting, Hentz was standing on the steps and handed him the fact sheet. Moore, a Springdale resident and Princeton parent, testified he was nowhere nearby. But Darby said Moore was standing behind Hentz at the time.
The fact sheet stated that Higgins was a defendant in a lawsuit by an African-American student. That was true at the time, former CPS general counsel John Concannon said, but the lawsuit was later found to be without merit. Concannon said the four other items on the sheet were false and constituted a vicious attack on a good man.
Bronson: Kids, council need to do the right thing
Blackwell pushes for end to secret political accounts
Car buffs donate $50K to hospital
TOP LOCAL HEADLINES
Ohio wins new uranium plant
Dowlin refuses DeWine debate
Deal avoids primary battle
Lawyer asks out of church lawsuit
Public library doing more with less
Arrest led to deputy
Biographer to speak on 'soul' of pope
District loses commandments court battle
Man killed at bar's door
Builder's racketeering conviction upheld
Drug arrests follow probe of Cheviot bar
Fantasy reading makes TV disappear
Principal wins slander suit
NKU foresees rise in tuition
Police say couple took sex photos of students
Sports commentator to speak at Moeller
Blighted area reawakens
Visits by 'Apple Lady' bear fruit for patients
Lakeside Park agrees to study merger with Crestview Hills
Loveland debate canceled
Mall tops list of Crestview Hills mayor's goals
Indian Hill relaxes cell-phone tower rule
Water compromise pondered
Computer training available in city
John Iden, ballet pianist