Sunday, January 25, 2004

Cool concept: freezing human eggs

Norwood group tests method that could transform industry

By Tim Bonfield
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Sue Ekk, an embryologist at the Institute for Reproductive Health in Norwood, demonstrates the placing of a sperm in an egg, or the ICSI procedure, that is used at the clinic in cases of male factor infertility.
(Craig Ruttle/The
Cincinnati Enquirer)
Science of fertility growing up fast 
In one of the newest, and still experimental, fertility treatments available, the Institute for Reproductive Health has launched a clinical trial to attempt freezing the eggs for up to 20 women.

The Norwood-based center joins a handful of centers nationwide that have pumped years of research into a concept that could transform the fertility industry.

If successful, the concept of egg freezing will throw new wrinkles into the right-to-life debate and could have far-reaching influences on how and when people choose to become parents.

"Egg freezing is huge. It would change almost everything," says Dr. Sherif Awadalla, the lead partner in the Institute for Reproductive Health.

Young women who haven't found their ideal husband or want to spend more time building a career could set aside eggs and have babies years down the line.

Young women diagnosed with cancer would gain new options for having children later in life instead of accepting infertility from radiation and chemotherapy treatments.

The big challenge facing such ideas: reliability. So far, success rates have been sketchy at best.

"Egg cryopreservation is definitely here to stay. But I still don't think there's quite enough clinical experience yet for women to start stashing away eggs," says Dr. Michael Tucker, lab director of the Fertility Centers of Illinois.

In 1997, Dr. Tucker was involved with the first U.S. birth from a frozen egg, which occurred in Atlanta.

Scientists have long been able to successfully thaw frozen sperm and, more recently, have reported success at thawing frozen human embryos. But success at freezing a woman's eggs has been rare.

The problem has been that tiny human eggs are still much larger and contain much more water than sperm cells or embryonic cells. As a result, there's more risk of crucial chromosome-laden fibers within the eggs being destroyed by frozen water crystals.

For years, scientists have hunted for ways around this problem by adjusting the pace of the freezing process and by using various chemicals to protect the egg structures during freezing. Now, some successes are being reported.

In nearby Indianapolis, Dr. Jeffrey Boldt has reported delivering eight babies using a new freezing method. Dr. Awadalla's center will follow the Indianapolis protocol.

If freezing eggs proves successful, the entire fertility industry could change in several ways.

• The cottage industry of egg donation - an act of charity for some friends of infertile couples and a way of making money for some young women - could evolve into industrial-scale egg banking.

• Frozen eggs could simplify the issues that swirl around the fate of unused fertilized embryos and the decisions to abort some babies in multiple pregnancies.

• Egg freezing would offer new options to young women diagnosed with cancer.

In theory, even a teenager with leukemia who is nowhere near ready for parenthood could have some eggs frozen before starting radiation or chemotherapy treatments.

Some doctors, however, remain skeptical about the value of egg freezing for cancer patients. It may prove quicker and safer to remove and freeze an entire ovary rather than delay cancer treatments for several weeks while fertility drugs take effect to generate several eggs, Tucker said.

Regardless of the potential applications, much more study is needed before egg freezing becomes routine, says Dr. Pradeep Warikoo, a fertility expert at the Bethesda Center for Reproductive Health in Montgomery.

"Right now, the data isn't all that convincing," Warikoo says. "Some centers are trying to make a business out of oocyte banking, but what happens in 10 or 20 years when they try to thaw the eggs and find out there's a 10 percent survival rate?"

Science of fertility growing up fast
Cool concept: freezing human eggs
Taft sticks with high-tech goal
Third Frontier's three-legged plan two-thirds funded
Fugitive developer arrested in N.Y.
Good deeds precede buildup to rivalry
Summit classes move to XU
Seniors fear for records
Barton case topic of town
Bicentennial year left Ohio jubilant

Winter storm forecast: snow, ice, warmth, rain, snow
2 college branches planned
Kids take school's measure
Anti-abortion crowd rallies
Blue Ash enlarges, revamps fire dept.
Fire destroys house in Columbia Tusculum
Bright ideas compete for prize
Bill caps yearly tuition increases
Budget problems threaten scholarships for Guardsmen
Team ready to deliver sextuplets
Public safety briefs
Faith Matters

Radel: Moeller grad helps survivors of USS Indianapolis disaster
Bronson: Sometimes, shelter just isn't enough
Good things happening: Buffalo Soldier to tell history

Agnes Hall, Scout leader

Teachers wary of definitions
Election agency won't appeal ruling against campaign finance laws