By Jennifer Edwards
The Cincinnati Enquirer
HYDE PARK - Ten days after a portion of Summit Country Day School's main building collapsed, the principal contractor said workers knew the site required special shoring to prevent such an accident.
Montessori teacher Regina Sansalone carries Devin Scarborough while leading Emma Rademacher by the hand as they get a look at their temporary classroom at Crossroads Community Church in Oakley on Wednesday.|
(Glenn Hartong photo)
A pre-construction soils report prepared for Summit warned that foundations in the 114-year-old main building needed extra support during construction of an adjacent building.
"Everybody knew we were building next to adjacent structures and there were strong requirements in some areas," Rich Homan, vice president/general manager of Turner Construction Co.'s Cincinnati office downtown, said Wednesday.
No one was injured Jan. 18 during the Sunday morning collapse, which toppled three stories.
School was closed last week and reopened Wednesday. Nearly 250 preschool and kindergarten students will finish the school year off campus, attending classes at Crossroads Community Church in Oakley. Summit's 317 high school students will finish classes at Xavier University.
The rest of Summit, its first through eighth grades, returned to campus Wednesday in areas separate from the main building.
Turner, which has several subcontractors on the project, immediately brought in a crisis team.
"I think everybody was pretty surprised. This is not done in any haphazard manner," he said. "There is a lot of detail and thought given into this. We have been in business 100 years, and I can't remember something like this happening."
A demolition crew has removed the buckled fourth story and suspended roof of the main building.
"We live and die by our reputation, and we stand up and do the right thing," Homan said. "Over the last, I would say, nine years, we have done $600 million in K-12 work (building schools). It's a big part of what we do. We have been very successful at it, and I am pretty proud of how our team responded to this crisis."
Summit officials said they continue to have faith in Turner. The company is working to meet a September deadline for an $11 million construction project for a new Lower School for Montessori and elementary students.
In a preliminary assessment last week, Bill Langevin, director of Cincinnati's buildings and inspections department, said workers dug too deep, too close to the existing foundation. In addition, he said, bad weather and a previously undetected difference in the depth of foundations of the collapsed portion of the building likely contributed.
The pre-construction report is included in the drawing plans for the construction project done by the architect, Homan said .
"The geotechincal report is built into the design documents, so that information is provided to the designer and put on the drawings - and we build on those," Homan said. "The architects utilized the report as a basis for their design. It's a very collaborative process. Everybody was aware of all this information.
"Whenever you're up against an existing building, there is a plan that is developed and the city is involved, the architect is involved, the engineer is involved - so everybody is trying to make sure the plan works."
Homan declined Wednesday to discuss Langevin's assessment on the collapse. "I don't think anybody has the true facts yet," he said. "I have high regard for Mr. Langevin ... but the fact of the matter is there are quite a few engineers, very smart people, out on the site now investigating the cause."
Gov. Taft stresses jobs, tax overhaul
Businesses liked tone, but wonder how it can be done
UC transplant doc receives new liver
Oxford's WOXY Net-only after sale
Summit students back at school
Summit pupils feel right at home
Twitty's conviction erased from the record
IN THE TRISTATE
One hurt in plant fire in Madison Township
Fest plans to reclaim 'Cinco'
Columbia Twp. administrator renewed
Expulsions will be fewer
Dute to be retried on charges of pandering
Eastern corridor transit plans open for discussion
Motive will determine sentencing in slaying
Felicity library observes 10th year
Junk cars, blaring stereos to be cited by Fairfield cops
Last funds hurdle cleared
Faith better than being cool, Bengals' Kitna tells students
Lakota lists cutbacks if levy fails
Middletown schools to trim
Warren deputy released on bond in drug case
Judge: Allen must testify
Norwood rejects contract negotiated for firefighters
Business adviser to Haitians uses what he learned
Public safety briefs
Lynch opposes police hiring
District head is award winner
Hall pass or not, this baby's coming
Money reallocated to veterans service
Volunteers may oversee W. Chester money issues
Yard sign restriction challenged in court
Bronson: Adult battles could ruin kids' games
Crowley: Ruby saves his first team for late-night meal
Good Things Happening
Burlington seeks sidewalk help
Church's bank accounts investigated
NKU thrilled with budget