Friday, March 12, 2004

NFL denies acting as monopoly


League responds to county lawsuit on stadium deal

By Dan Horn
The Cincinnati Enquirer

NFL officials denied Thursday that the league acted as a monopoly during negotiations to build Paul Brown Stadium, forcing Hamilton County into an unfair lease agreement.

The denial came a day after county commissioners voted 2-0 to join a federal antitrust lawsuit that accuses the Bengals and the NFL of abusing the power of a monopoly over professional football.

The suit seeks to recover more than $200 million of the $450 million spent to acquire land and build the stadium, which opened in 2000.

Although the NFL is the nation's only major pro football league, NFL spokesman Greg Aiello said that was not a factor in stadium negotiations.

He said voters and local leaders could have chosen to spend the money on a variety of other sports or entertainment facilities, or to spend it on something else entirely.

"We are not a monopoly in any context that is relevant here," Aiello said. "We have no monopoly power in respect to the city and the county."

The lawsuit claims the NFL violates federal antitrust laws because it restricts public ownership of teams, misleads communities about the economic condition of its franchises and uses the threat of relocating franchises to win huge concessions.

Negotiations to build the stadium in Cincinnati took place after the Bengals threatened to leave town.

The Bengals' lease is among the most generous in the NFL, and commissioners now claim the deal was made only because the league and the team broke antitrust rules.

Aiello said the league acted appropriately and both the county's voters and elected officials agreed to invest in the stadium.

"An NFL franchise delivers substantial benefits to a community. It's by no means a one-way street," Aiello said. "There never was any sound basis for attacking the underlying arrangements. That continues to be true today."

E-mail dhorn@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Run that light and smile
Fans of symphony soon will pay more
Couple marries as judges debate
NFL denies acting as monopoly
Sumatran rhino pregnant again, this time without progesterone

IN THE TRISTATE
Author says start singing - and diversify the church
Butler faces budget cut as soon as next month
Stoker seeks different vets site
68 children to perform in world premiere at UC
Man convicted in fatal beating of his mother
Police: 'Victim' lied in hidden gun case
Green Beer Day goes flat
Human Relations Commission hires Hispanics' liaison
News briefs
Two get maximums for murderous spree
Residents say creek contains sewage
Milford students charged after drug sweep at school
Neighbors briefs
Bill urges fighting drugged driving
Hall table days SO over; in-school stores the rule
Clogged pumps cause house flooding
Joy ride in field led to fatal crash

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Downs: Cicadas to be toast of town with parties
Good Things Happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
William Crumes, civil rights pioneer
Ruby W. Rapp, 90, radio, TV personality

KENTUCKY STORIES
Kentucky briefs
Sierra Club to protest Cheney
Judge won't pursue state post
Financing set for new mall
Ky. 'no-knock' communities expanding