Friday, March 19, 2004

Attorney-client case again before court



By Janice Morse
The Cincinnati Enquirer

In the latest skirmish over attorney-client secrets in a missing child case, prosecutors Thursday asked the Ohio Supreme Court to stick to its earlier decision ordering a lawyer to reveal what a now-deceased client may have shared about the 1999 disappearance of Erica Baker.

"There is nothing in this decision that the court has overlooked or got wrong," Montgomery County Prosecutor Mathias H. Heck Jr. said in a document filed with the Supreme Court. "(The attorney's) theories have received a thorough airing in the Common Pleas Court, the Court of Appeals and this Court."

Lawyers representing Dayton-area attorney Beth Lewis have asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its precedent-setting March 3 decision that Lewis must tell what client Jan Marie Franks, who died in 2001, may have known about Erica. The girl was 9 when she disappeared in Kettering.

Prosecutors want Lewis to answer a grand jury's questions about tips that Franks might have been in a van that accidentally struck EricaTipsters claimed that van's occupants panicked and disposed of Erica's body, her relatives said.

The Supreme Court and two other courts said Lewis would be compelled to testify under a 1953 Ohio law. The law says a surviving spouse may waive a deceased spouse's attorney-client privilege.

E-mail jmorse@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Iraq campaign altered warfare
Pride mixes with pain of losing a son
Careless teenage drivers on collision course
1 month: 6 wrecks, 7 deaths
Tougher teen-driving laws sought for Ohio, Ky.
Trustee not guilty of gun charge

McCoy may be in Ohio soon
Hands-on fair teaches students about health
High schoolers enter science tournament
Language festival fosters fluency
'Friendly cod' signs reel in people for church fish fry
Youth drama group hopes play helps teens deal with emotions
Retail departures don't alarm Springdale

IN THE TRISTATE
Enquirer honors 10 women at luncheon
New Southwest Landmark alarms block ammonia theft
Prosecutor opposes Broadnax expungement
Jarvi leads dramatic preview of CSO tour
Attorney-client case again before court
Group steps up for extracurriculars
Academic all-stars
Public safety briefs

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Maggie Downs: 'Lips' finally puts a chick in White House
Good things happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
Richard H. Fletcher, 88, avid swimmer
Samuel Gamble, 91, was mayor, business owner

KENTUCKY STORIES
First Baptist lawyers quit
Probe targets closed center
Teacher charged with 10 more instances of molestation
Letter said 'Try to catch me'; cops did
Fletcher plan hits wall in House
Robberies may have tie, police say
Young GOP group formed
Firefighters battle fires at plant, empty house
Principal-hiring bill seems dead
Voters approve of cocktails at country club in Mayfield
State asks hearing on perjury charge
Court: County notified public of tax

Kentucky obituaries
Kentucky briefs