Thursday, March 25, 2004

Commandments must go


Circuit Court agrees posting in public buildings is illegal

The Associated Press

The full 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati will not reconsider the decision of a three-judge panel that ruled the Ten Commandments should not be posted in public buildings in Kentucky, even if the religious laws are accompanied by other historical documents.

McCreary and Pulaski county officials hung framed copies of the Ten Commandments in their courthouses and later added other documents, such as the Magna Carta and Declaration of Independence, after the display was challenged.

Harlan County had similar displays in its schools.

In a 2-1 decision in December 2002, the three-judge panel upheld U.S. District Judge Jennifer Coffman's 2001 preliminary order to remove the displays until the conclusion of a lawsuit challenging their constitutionality.

The full court issued a ruling Tuesday denying the request to reconsider the December ruling.

Coffman said in her 2001 ruling that the purpose of displaying the Ten Commandments was "religious in nature."

She said the fact that the displays began with just the Ten Commandments and only later added the other documents "bolstered the reasonable observer's perception of the state endorsement of religion."

Erik Stanley, an attorney representing the counties, said legal avenues will be pursued to get the displays back up.

"We're going to petition the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the case," he said Wednesday.

"We have 90 days to do that."




TOP STORIES
Erpenbecks switching to guilty pleas
Hanging chads proving costly
Angina cure a step closer
Political spending will zoom
Working for a safer Avondale

IN THE TRISTATE
Ohio's taxes blamed for flight
Calling all Butler County Democrats: Run this race
Energetic cast, crew shine in Beechwood High's 'Annie'
'Just happy to be alive,' but much more than that
Judges struggle with Flynt case
Center names spokeswoman
Green Twp. may need levy this fall
Zoning change opens land for supercenter
News briefs
Senior housing planned
Mutation linked to lung disease in newborns
Workshop to explain three Lunken options
New wastewater plant increases Mason capacity
Neighbors briefs
Newtown slaying still a mystery
Public safety briefs
Price Hill to plan for new elementary
Taking Fernald back to nature
Montgomery to choose developer in April
Money sought for baseball diamonds

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Bronson: Lack of faith in City Council leads to Angels
Crowley: Henry wants Kentucky to have a surgeon general
Summit continues helping heart fund

LIVES REMEMBERED
Ernest Mauer was star at Newport High

KENTUCKY STORIES
Commandments must go
N.Ky chamber endorses tax plan
Furnish gets death penalty a second time
Senate panel OKs price-gouging bill
Gun Shops in the Home
Thieves take kegs, leave dirt behind
Flowers add more color to purple bridge
Clooney, Davis spar over polls