Thursday, March 25, 2004

Newtown slaying still a mystery

By Howard Wilkinson
The Cincinnati Enquirer

NEWTOWN - Sheriff's deputies were no closer Wednesday to finding James Chisenhall's killer than they were Sunday morning, when the 45-year-old night clerk's bullet-riddled body was found on the floor of a Church Street convenience store.

"There are no suspects and no real leads," said Steve Barnett of the Hamilton County Sheriff's Office, which has been investigating the shooting at the Shell gas station and convenience store since Sunday morning, when Newtown police handed off the investigation.

Chisenhall, a Milford resident who worked the overnight shift at the store, died at University Hospital shortly after being found lying on the floor of the office area about 2 a.m. Sunday.

At the noon hour Wednesday, a steady stream of customers came in and out of the store, many of them leaving $1, $5 and $10 bills in a bowl on the counter next to a picture of Chisenhall. The money, a store employee said, is being collected to support the family of the slain clerk, who leaves behind a wife, seven children and eight grandchildren.

Donations for the Jim Chisenhall Sr. Memorial Family Fund are also being taken at all Fifth Third Bank locations.

The homicide in Newtown, a village of 2,400 in the middle of Anderson Township, was the first in 17 years.

Mayor John Hammon said people in the village are talking about Chisenhall's death, although the subject did not come up at Tuesday night's Village Council meeting.

"This is a small town and people aren't used to this kind of thing here," said Hammon. "It shocked a lot of people."

Hammon said he does not think most people in Newtown knew the victim, because of the shift he worked.

"But, still, it is an awful thing to have happen," Hammon said.

Hammon said he does not know if the Chisenhall's slaying - which police believe was the result of an armed robbery attempt - will mean increased police patrols overnight by the village's 11-member police force.

"The chief runs the department; that would be his call," Hammon said.

Police Chief Daryl Zornes declined to comment on the convenience-store shooting.

Barnett said Wednesday the case is being investigated as a robbery-homicide.

In most convenience-store robberies, police are aided by videotape from store security cameras, but deputies found a camera with no videotape at the Newtown store.

"It's not clear if the videotape was taken by whoever did this or if there wasn't any tape in the machine," Barnett said.

Barnett said the case was unusual because it took place in the middle of a small town, far from any interstate highway entrances that give a robber or robbers a quick escape.


Erpenbecks switching to guilty pleas
Hanging chads proving costly
Angina cure a step closer
Political spending will zoom
Working for a safer Avondale

Ohio's taxes blamed for flight
Calling all Butler County Democrats: Run this race
Energetic cast, crew shine in Beechwood High's 'Annie'
'Just happy to be alive,' but much more than that
Judges struggle with Flynt case
Center names spokeswoman
Green Twp. may need levy this fall
Zoning change opens land for supercenter
News briefs
Senior housing planned
Mutation linked to lung disease in newborns
Workshop to explain three Lunken options
New wastewater plant increases Mason capacity
Neighbors briefs
Newtown slaying still a mystery
Public safety briefs
Price Hill to plan for new elementary
Taking Fernald back to nature
Montgomery to choose developer in April
Money sought for baseball diamonds

Bronson: Lack of faith in City Council leads to Angels
Crowley: Henry wants Kentucky to have a surgeon general
Summit continues helping heart fund

Ernest Mauer was star at Newport High

Commandments must go
N.Ky chamber endorses tax plan
Furnish gets death penalty a second time
Senate panel OKs price-gouging bill
Gun Shops in the Home
Thieves take kegs, leave dirt behind
Flowers add more color to purple bridge
Clooney, Davis spar over polls