Thursday, April 1, 2004

Heimlich, Portune chastise Dowlin



By Cindi Andrews
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Two Hamilton County commissioners accused the third - John Dowlin - of sandbagging their attempts to sue the Cincinnati Bengals and the National Football League Wednesday.

"It is very clear to me that you are acting in conjunction with those who want to derail this lawsuit," fellow Republican Phil Heimlich told Dowlin.

Dowlin, in turn, accused Heimlich and Commissioner Todd Portune of ignoring the county prosecutor's office, which is paid by taxpayers to act as the board's legal counsel.

The exchange took place just before commissioners voted 2-1 for a contract for attorneys Stanley Chesley and Robert Furnier. Dowlin voted no. Portune and Heimlich announced plans to hire the lawyers three weeks ago to represent the county in a federal antitrust lawsuit.

The suit alleges pro football used a monopoly to force the county to build the Bengals a stadium. It was first filed by Portune as an individual in 2003, but Groesbeck resident Carrie Davis has since replaced him.

The suit seeks up to $600 million in damages, but Portune and Heimlich say all they really want is to renegotiate the Bengals' lease of Paul Brown Stadium. The stadium opened in 2000, but the $451 million bill is still being paid off via a half-penny sales tax approved by Hamilton County voters in 1996.

Wednesday's deal with Chesley and Furnier gives the attorneys a quarter of any money they win from the Bengals and the NFL within a year, or a third of any money they win after that. They also receive three to four times their hourly rates for any successful efforts to win nonmonetary concessions, such as the team relinquishing some control it has over riverfront development.

"They only get paid if they win," Portune said.

With one exception: The attorneys can also collect triple their standard fees if the commissioners later decide to accept a settlement for no money against Chesley's and Furnier's advice. That's insurance against a future Board of County Commissioners deciding to drop the suit in midstream, Portune said.

Anderson Township Trustee Russ Jackson filed a taxpayer lawsuit Monday challenging the legality of the commissioners hiring the lawyers on a contingency. State law allows commissioners to spend up to Prosecutor Mike Allen's annual salary - about $109,000 - without his approval.

Dowlin voiced similar concerns Wednesday.

"It seems like we are undermining the county prosecutor," he said. "I think he is being ignored. ... I'm led to believe the prosecutor has questions which he seems to think are valid with regard to this contract."

E-mail candrews@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Luken presses probe of gang
Songs of the cicadas: Oh, love is in the air
Senators want center audits
EPA head predicts cleaner air soon

IN THE TRISTATE
Bush: VP Cheney to toss 1st pitch at Reds' opener
Recount begins next week
City grants $1.3M to arts
EPA assays role in lead case
Parents' group underwrites sports programs in Franklin
Glenn talks of integrity at Miami
Green Township offers landowner $600,000 for wooded area
Top judge backs disclosure bill
Little Miami pitches expansion plans
Heimlich, Portune chastise Dowlin
Calendar changed to accommodate move
Celebration unites religions, cultures in single purpose
Law doesn't fault shooting suspect's family
State delays forcing voting-system decision
Warren Republicans split chairman's job
Housing hiatus gaining support
Street preacher sues XU over speech
Public safety briefs
News briefs

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Crowley: Did Bunning's so-called joke go too far?
Bronson: This grant just perfect for April 1
Terrace Park team to race for diabetes

LIVES REMEMBERED
Herbert Edelman, executive, hobbyist

KENTUCKY STORIES
Fletcher filling positions slowly, re-evaluating some
Paramedic coverage costly
Ludlow to lop school expenses
Murphy program pushes for jobs
New controls on body piercing