Friday, April 2, 2004

Son gets 8 years, judge's sympathy


Mother assigned blame in own death

By Sharon Coolidge
The Cincinnati Enquirer

The aunt of a man who bludgeoned his mother to death with a claw hammer said her sister's obsessive behavior was partly to blame for her death.

"Diane (Engelhardt) created the monster, and the monster killed her," according to Debbie Rogers.

Rogers' comments came in a letter to Judge Norbert Nadel before he sentenced her nephew, Frederick Engelhardt, 32, to eight years in prison for voluntary manslaughter and gross abuse of a corpse on Thursday.

Engelhardt's attorney Timothy Cutcher and family members said he learned of his father's suicide when he was 7, after which his mother isolated herself and her son from the world. Engelhardt wasn't allowed to have friends.

Judge Nadel of Hamilton County Common Pleas Court said Engelhardt had a "Norman Bates-type relationship" with his 57-year-old mother, referring to the murderous character obsessed with his mother in the Alfred Hitchcock movie, Psycho.

"I have a great deal of sympathy for the victim and sympathy for the defendant," Nadel said. "It was a bad situation."

Still, the brutal nature of the crime called for prison time, Nadel said.

"It will be nothing new for him, his entire life has been an imprisonment without walls," Nadel said.

Engelhardt could have imposed up to 10 years on the manslaughter charge, plus one year for the gross abuse of a corpse.

Assistant Hamilton County Prosecutor Mark Piepmeier argued for the maximum sentence.

"He is incapable of functioning in society," Piepmeier said. "I know he's been compared to Norman Bates, and that's legitimate, but the court would be reluctant to put Norman Bates on probation."

Engelhardt was charged with bludgeoning his mother to death on July 29, 2002. Prosecutors said he used a claw hammer on the back of her head eight times, then once more after she fell to the ground. Engelhardt put her body into a cistern behind their Colerain Township home.

Eight months later, investigators discovered the body.

Engelhardt said his mother attacked him first, so he grabbed the hammer and fought back.

"I wish it didn't happen. I wish I could take it back," he said. "I have to live with the guilt and nightmares the rest of my life."

When Nadel asked why he stayed at home even after becoming an adult, Engelhardt said, "I thought if I left it would destroy our relationship.

"She threatened to disown me," he said. "She was the only thing I had left in the world."

E-mail scoolidge@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Erpenbeck gets two 30-year terms
Now Bengals lawsuit has Hamilton Co. suing itself
Local roads kicked to the curb
Landmark Trinity school calls it quits
Little Miami mourns for teen

IN THE TRISTATE
School lead cleanup may cost $500,000
Play about Holocaust coming to Xavier U
Son gets 8 years, judge's sympathy
Geography veteran prepped for contest
Plans under way for senior ball
News briefs
Spas suspected of prostitution searched
Neighbors briefs
Norwood delays payment on bonds
Two cases of whooping cough reported
Lawson, ex-client trade jabs
Highway shooting suspect indicted
Model finalist also a role model for teens
Viet memorial advocate battled early resistance
Voting machine decision closer

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Downs: Harmony via talk, starring The Dean

LIVES REMEMBERED
Hannah Baird, community leader
Allen Brown fought for civil liberties

KENTUCKY STORIES
Two men rob Covington grocery store
Police investigating alleged embezzlement
Engineer leaves 6 cities without one
Two meth labs, one road
Play an act of devotion
UK profs feeling sting of cuts
N.Ky. veterans had hand in memorial