Saturday, May 1, 2004

Rookwood backers, opponents file briefs


Argument is about 'eminent domain'

By Steve Kemme
The Cincinnati Enquirer

Does Norwood have the right to take private property needed for a developer's planned outdoor mall? Proponents and opponents presented arguments in written statements submitted Friday to Hamilton County Common Pleas Court.

Attorneys for five property owners who don't want to sell say Norwood acted illegally in declaring the neighborhood blighted and trying to seize the property.

Timothy Burke, attorney for Norwood, said in his statement that the tax revenue from Rookwood Exchange will be critical to the financially struggling city. Norwood is facing a $3.5 million deficit.

If Norwood can't use eminent domain to take property, "Norwood will suffer as a community, and those many residents of the area who want to move on will be left struggling in a neighborhood that time has passed by."

Some time after oral arguments May 20, Judge Beth Myers will decide whether Norwood has the legal right to use eminent domain to seize the five properties for urban renewal. She also will decide if the city's procedure for seizing the properties is constitutional.

The object of this legal battle is a triangular piece of land bordered by Interstate 71, Rookwood Commons, Edwards Road and Williams Avenue.

The developers, Anderson Real Estate and the Miller-Valentine Group, want to demolish all the homes and businesses in that area and build the Rookwood Exchange, a $125 million complex of offices, shopping and residences.

Two private homeowners and three businesses, with free legal representation from the Institute of Justice, a non-profit group in Washington, D.C., are challenging Norwood's action. Sixty-five of 71 property owners in the proposed development site want to sell their homes to the developers. One business owner is negotiating with the developers.

E-mail skemme@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Once again, Culbersons wait in hope and dread
It was robbery suspects' lucky day
City sends horse out to pasture; family upset
Fernald cleanup slows down

IN THE TRISTATE
Breast cancer patients network
Fairfield's looking swell in classic 'Hello, Dolly!'
Children's, Medical Mutual without contract at deadline
Lot sizes may increase
Region's road deaths decline
Neighbors briefs
Rookwood backers, opponents file briefs
5-year-old suspended for having pocketknife
Feds, mayor at odds over force reports
Alcohol level 0.22 in man cops shot
Presidential rivals 'carded'
Public safety briefs
School construction plan shrinks
Students compete in Science Bowl

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Prayer day aims to help heal nation
Good Things Happening

LIVES REMEMBERED
J. Herbert Heger, educator
Sister Caroline, 93, long-time teacher

KENTUCKY STORIES
Cemetery restoration taught
Day for celebs, parties and - oh yes - the race
One year, 500,000 liters of beer
Agents seize 50 pounds of marijuana, arrest five
Many worries for Ky. teachers