Thursday, May 6, 2004

Seven more out of diocese abuse suit


They will pursue direct settlement

By Jim Hannah
The Cincinnati Enquirer

BURLINGTON - The judge presiding over a class-action sex-abuse lawsuit against the Covington Diocese has ruled that seven people could withdraw from the litigation despite missing the deadline to opt out.

"I think my clients are very, very relieved they are allowed to choose their own avenue in resolving their claims," B. Dahlenburg Bonar, a Covington attorney who is representing the seven people.

The seven, whose names have been kept confidential by a court order, have been fighting to be removed from the suit for two months. They hope to follow the path of 41 other abuse victims who have collectively received about $8.6 million since September.

The order makes it unclear how many people remain in the suit. The suit made international headlines in October when it became the first sex-abuse suit against a Roman Catholic diocese to be given class-action status. It is attempting to prove that the Northern Kentucky diocese mishandled claims of sexual abuse against its clergymen since the 1950s.

Two who will be allowed to opt out had argued that they were not informed of their right to leave the class. Four said they did not become aware of their right to opt out until after the deadline had passed.

The seventh person's attempt to opt out was challenged because his handwriting wasn't legible. Class-action attorney Robert Steinberg said he couldn't read the person's signature.

Steinberg had argued the seven should remain a part of the suit. He challenged the claim that he had not given people adequate notice of the opt-out date.

The opt-out form had been published several times in Cincinnati's two daily newspapers, three times in USA Today, two times in 20 additional daily newspapers and once in 90 weekly newspapers.

Steinberg said some of the people had also been told of an Internet site his firm built to inform people of the suit.

Senior Judge John Potter, who is presiding over the case, wrote in his ruling that the one person who didn't legibly write his name must resubmit the form.

Potter wrote there would be no legal reason to allow the seven to circumvent normal opt-out procedures if Steinberg had not agreed at a Oct. 20 hearing to accept opt-out forms turned in a "little bit late."

Potter warned that others would not be allowed to opt out. Too much time had passed since Steinberg said he would accept late forms to allow anyone else to leave the suit, his ruling said.

E-mail jhannah@enquirer.com




TOP STORIES
Teens' Nerf guns raise ruckus
Grad launched Dart Wars rules
Downtown to get $50 million boost
Bush pauses to comfort teen
Student undercount has state scrambling for funds

IN THE TRISTATE
Educators can feed violence problem in schools, expert says
Breast cancer united these neighbors
Ex-cop may be rehired
Cicada questions bugging you? Here's some help
Sports car provides inspiration for class
City's Clean Air Act targets polluters
4th dog joining hunt for woman's remains
Deerfield Twp. meeting sizzles in acrimony
Plan to build Y questioned
Con man's crimes also taint Deters
Soldier says thanks for mail
2 Nigerian men charged with stealing identities
Inside of 2 Lexington Manor homes to be tested for lead
Schools make plea for money
Dixie, Holy Cross scholars win grants
Senate passes lawsuit limits, but House will not be rushed
Lawsuit fights gay-marriage petition drive
Fitton Center, Butler schools team on arts
Science team just short of finals
Neighbors briefs
News briefs

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Crowley: Mongiardo's errors not Rx for success
Bronson: Shots-and-beer defense shot down by judge

LIVES REMEMBERED
Moe Burtschy, pitched for A's in Philly, KC

KENTUCKY STORIES
Lobbyists spent less on 2004 General Assembly
Teens held for theft, chase
Boone spurns 128-house Buffalo Trace subdivision
Retail-office center awaits vote
Seven more out of diocese abuse suit
Campbell High's antics have a serious purpose
Restaurant that trains disabled needs a hand
3-year-old wanders several blocks