Sunday, May 9, 2004

Spring water's health benefits weighed against contaminants

By Roger Alford
The Associated Press

PINEVILLE, Ky. - Melvin Money, a spry 73-year-old, kneels to get his fill of mineral water gushing out of a mountain spring in southeastern Kentucky.

"It's the purest water you can find," he said, holding a plastic jug beneath a spout that flows constantly on the shaded campus of Clear Creek Baptist Bible College. "It's supposed to be really healthy water. My mother drank it. She lived to be 95."

In a routine that harkens back to days of old, Money makes frequent treks to the spring, preferring the pure mineral water with the distinctive, earthy flavor to the purified municipal brand that's piped into his home.

People in Appalachia are rediscovering the natural springs that were the primary water supply for early settlers in the mountain region. Some of the springs, like the one on the Clear Creek campus, have become so popular that people drive from as far away as Virginia and Tennessee to fill up.

Officials warn of pollution

It's a trend that has caught the attention of government regulators, who warn that some springs could be polluted with contaminants that might make people ill.

"When it comes to spring water quality, it's a tricky subject," said Rob Blair, a geologist who monitors ground water for the Kentucky Division of Water. "You see a lot of variation in quality. You can pull a sample one day, and it will be clean. Go back tomorrow and it could be the most contaminated water you've ever seen."

That, Blair said, depends on the source of the water going into the underground reservoirs that feed springs. If it is surface water percolating underground from a farm, he said, pesticides, herbicides and harmful bacteria from animal waste could be fed into the spring water.

"There are springs out there that are relatively safe, but if people asked me point blank if they should drink from a spring, I would say no," Blair said. "If you're drinking raw water right out of the ground, you are running a risk of getting sick. It runs the gamut from stomach cramps to worse. If it's real bad, it could be fatal."

Some 130,000 people in Kentucky who rely entirely on spring water for drinking, bathing and other needs might argue otherwise. They raise concerns about the safety of water drawn from polluted lakes and streams by municipalities, treated with chlorine, and pumped into homes.

Tap water concerns

Concern about the safety of tap water from public sources has helped to fuel the interest in alternative sources, whether bottled water from retail stores or from a natural spring down the road, said Bill Miller, president of the National Spring Water Association in Johnson City, Tenn.

What people may not understand, Miller said, is that bottled spring water comes from commercial springs that have passed stringent government testing, not from small springs that regulators may not even know about.

"I wouldn't drink from just any spring I came upon," Miller said. "I cringe when I see somebody filling a jug from a pipe coming out of the ground.

Search for healthier water

Miller said the spring water trend may also be an outgrowth of the search for healthier water. Instead of deciding among various brands of bottled water on store shelves, they're choosing to bottle their own, straight from the springs.

"They hear the controversy about whether what they're buying in stores is actually spring water," Miller said. "When they go get it themselves, they know what they're drinking is real spring water."

Miller said a natural spring would create a small pool of water that would support frogs, fish and other aquatic life. He said while such a pool could be easily contaminated, it could just as easily be protected against contamination by building a protective enclosure around it, as has been done at the Clear Creek spring, which is encased in concrete.

The Clear Creek spring has always been a focal point on campus - a gathering place for students, especially on hot days, said Jay Sulfridge, director of alumni relations at the Bible college. Now, they happily share the space with people from off-campus who come regularly, plastic jugs in hand, to get spring water.

Dear Mom . . .
Tribute to a voice too soon stilled
More letters to Mom
Drivers grump, but still pump
Now, Cicada Survival 101

Anderson green space grows
Musician's heritage strikes chord at Appalachian Fest
No charges expected in Ky. boat crash that injured two
Della Reese shares story of diabetes, healthy life
Salvage yard fire leads to explosions
Park to be only for residents of Indian Hill
Desegregation celebrated
3,615 graduates receive degrees at commencement
July 4th fireworks dodges fizzle-out
Manslaughter charge brought in rioting case
Accused highway shooter seeks funds
Concealed-gun proponents complain process is onerous
700 volunteers fix homes for low-income residents

Bronson: President Bush proves that he is the real deal
Playing together spells success
Church site to be blessed

Marion J. Artmeier was nurse at Good Samaritan
Fr. Sylvester Heppner put his stamp on Bacon High

School gives itself the gift of its past
Governor's brother might not have any advantage
Roeding, Walton letting it rip
Spring water's benefits weighed against contaminants