Wednesday, May 12, 2004

Elections board deadlocks over sheriff candidate



By Sue Kiesewetter
Enquirer contributor

[photo]
Patton
HAMILTON - Ohio Secretary of State J. Kenneth Blackwell will decide whether retired Ohio State Highway Patrol Trooper Robert Patton will be a candidate for Butler County sheriff this fall.

In a 2-2 vote along party lines, the Butler County Board of Elections couldn't agree whether Patton met the qualifications for office.

Ohio law requires a candidate for sheriff to have served at the rank of sergeant if the candidate worked for the state patrol.

Patton retired last October after nearly 26 years of service - as a trooper.

But he argued that several times he has served as officer in charge, the equivalent to the rank of sergeant, when there was no sergeant on duty.

"Once Mr. Blackwell sees my letters of verification and statute he will rule in my favor," Patton said after the hearing.

"From everything I've heard he's a fair and honest man and he'll agree with me."

Patton is seeking to run as an independent candidate in the Nov. 2 election, replacing Sheriff Harold Gabbard, who is retiring. If allowed to run, Patton would face Republican Richard Jones, Gabbard's chief deputy; and Democrat Dale Richter, an officer with the Springboro Police Department.

In voting against putting Patton on the ballot, Republican Judy Shelton said she was relying on an April opinion from the prosecutor's office. Joe Schwarz, also a Republican, said that under state law, Patton doesn't qualify for the office.

"My job is not to legislate but to enforce the laws that legislators enact," Schwarz said.

Democrats Dan Gattermeyer and John Holcomb Jr. disagreed with the Republicans and voted in favor of Patton's candidacy.

"There's no case law on this particular situation," Gattermeyer said.

"By all accounts he had an outstanding career. I want to give voters the widest possible choice," Holcomb added.

In Warren County, Morrow Police Chief Richard H. Kilburn, cousin of County Commissioner Mike Kilburn, will challenge incumbent Warren County Sheriff Tom Ariss.

Meanwhile, Jack Chrisman of Lebanon, who was eyeing the county commissioner seat Larry Crisenbery is vacating, did not have enough signatures to put his name on the ballot, according to the Warren County Board of Elections.

Deerfield Township businessman Dave Young, who won the four-way Republican primary in March, now has no opponent.




TOP STORIES
Show of support
Mall rehab plan back on track
Bugs just waiting for good soaking
Fill 'er up? You sure?
Gas tax rising in Kentucky
Tot Lot was greedy, violent

IN THE TRISTATE
Home-inspection policy put on hold
Elections board deadlocks over sheriff candidate
Photographer freed during appeal
Culberson search yields clues
EPA approves off-road air rules
Emptying of silos opposed
Public views vary on polishing the Square
Pictures 'disastrous,' MU prof says
Juneteenth Festival still seeking funds
Lakota switches students; parents seethe
CareSource to increase lead-poison tests for kids
Portman praises Little Miami
Mental-health advocates rally at Ohio Statehouse
Norwood seeks 14-mill levy
Public safety briefs
West Chester strikes back
Witness may face order to appear
Brother on trial in killing of sister
Job creation for teens dwindling
News briefs
Neighbors briefs

ENQUIRER COLUMNISTS
Friendship park wins design award

LIVES REMEMBERED
Mary Lou Adams, 64, teacher, traveler

KENTUCKY STORIES
Center may get OK this week
Cincinnati ranked 44th of U.S. cities
Facades eligible for city grants
Ethics panel kills complaint against Senate leader's wife
Kerry pitches health plan
Kentucky News Briefs
Help to needy expands with thrift shop